Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Too much free time
date posted: Mar 01, 2007 7:00 PM
What if Qui-Gon......
What if Qui-Gon wasn't killed. How would that alter the star wars saga as we know it. Obi-Wan, being like a brother, to Anakin trained him, but if Qui-Gon had lived he would have trained Anakin. Qui-Gon (I thought) was the best father figure Anakin had before he met Obi-Wan. It ends up they were more like brothers which suggests that when Anakin was appointed to the council he considered himself an equal to Obi-Wan. Had Qui-Gon lived would Anakin,higher rank or not, respect his wishes more so than Obi-Wan. An example being when he went to Tatooine to find his mother, which contributed greatly to his turning to the dark side. He also had an understanding of Anakin in which Qui-Gon himself was angered with the council at times. Being able to relate could have created a stronger bond. Even if none of this helped and Anakin turned to the dark side anyway the story would change. Qui-Gon, instead of Obi-Wan, would face Anakin. Qui-Gon isn't as good a swordsman as Anakin. That's just a fact. So Anakin would have won the Mustafar battle, and wouldn't be confined to the suit which would make him an even more powerful sithlord. Qui-Gon wouldn't have learned his ability to immortality either. Luke wouldn't learn his training because Obi-Wan wouldn't convince Yoda to train him. The Empire would have ruled the galaxy. The dark side would have won the entire saga all because of Qui-Gon.

Since we're on the subject
why wasn't Qui-Gon with the 3 spirits at the end of Jedi?

gencrs
Technical Manuals from The GFFA
date Posted: Mar 01, 2007 8:20 PM
I think that even if Qui-Gon had lived to face Anakin on Mustafar and was killed there, Obi-Wan still would have gone fight Anakin. Remember the intensity that Obi-Wan had after Maul killed Qui-Gon. He would have had the same intensity, IMO, when fighting Darth Vader. But you've got a good point. The fact that Qui-Gon disagreed with the council's decision to train Anakin may have kept Anakin from turning. It probably would have kept Anakin and Padme from becoming close.

Interesting thoughts.

  Lord_ace_11135_0_o
Too much free time
date Posted: Mar 01, 2007 8:24 PM
i dont know if u ever read them
but the star wars infinity graphic novels were pretty cool
from the original trilogy
if one key point was changed
what would happen

if ur interested in alternate sw stories
u should check it out
  cayleldar
12 Parsecs or Bust (or) the Sith Who Knew Too Little
date Posted: Mar 01, 2007 8:37 PM
We have contemplated this ourselves. It's hard to tell, but we think that Anakin would not have turned to the Dark Side. If you pay attention in AOTC, Obi-Wans advise to Anakin throughout the movie was poor at best. Obi-Wan often treated Anakin as he thought a Jedi Master should, such as Yoda...
Old Ben- I thought that I could instruct him as well as Yoda...
Instead of following his instincts Obi-Wan comformed to what he thought was the "Taditional" way of instructing a padawan. Obi_Wan wasn't ready for someone like Anakin.

"May the Force be with me, myself, and I"
  Lord_ace_11135_0_o
Too much free time
date Posted: Mar 01, 2007 8:40 PM
Obi-Wan became a good teacher while instructing Luke no matter how short
but i agree
he wasn't the best when he trained Anakin
  the_wookiee_has_no_pants
Pantless Wookiee
date Posted: Mar 02, 2007 12:56 AM
Since we're on the subject
why wasn't Qui-Gon with the 3 spirits at the end of Jedi?


The three spirits all bore some relation to Luke, and he'd met them all. Qui-Gon doesn't really haev any direct relations to Luke as such, wherefore it wouldn't make sense if he showed up as a spirit.
  Lord_ace_11135_0_o
Too much free time
date Posted: Mar 02, 2007 7:48 AM
That makes sense
  Oriana Dantra
date Posted: Mar 02, 2007 9:58 AM
I've also thought about this. Imagine though, the scene when Obi-Wan jumps out Padme's apartment window after the assassin droid in AOTC. Now imagine Qui-Gon in his place. It made my sister and I laugh quite a bit !
  Lord_ace_11135_0_o
Too much free time
date Posted: Mar 02, 2007 1:21 PM
lol
yeah that would be funny
but again it could be possible that event would never take place
one little thing could alter the entire storyline.
  • Please log in to post comments