Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
date posted: Jan 21, 2008 8:06 AM  |  updated: Jan 21, 2008 4:32 PM
A Still Moment In A Galaxy Far, Far Away
I was watching the much maligned Attack of the Clones the other day, and I just couldn't help but pause - and replay a couple of times ;) - the elevator scene. You know - the one in which Obi-wan and Anakin are ascending one of Coruscant's towering buildings to offer Jedi protection to now Senator Padmé Amidala. It's the first time we seen the pair in 10 years (oh, let your imagination allow you to believe this! Remember what Yoda says: "Truly wonderful the mind of a child is." Aren't we all children, or at least young, at heart? :)). This is the first scene - and the best scene - that sets the stage for our understanding of Anakin's and Obi-wan's relationship. It is the scene that allows Obi-wan's heart-wrenching "You were my brother, Anakin. I loved you!" outburst at the end of Revenge of the Sith to be all the more heart wrenching, at least for me. My eyes well up every time I see the pained expression on Obi-wan's face in that ROTS scene - and it's all because of these few seconds of film in AOTC.

It is but one still moment in a galaxy far, far away that may be so easy to dismiss for many people, but has stuck in my head since the first time I saw AOTC.

Here is Obi-wan - Anakin's best friend, his mentor, his father figure all rolled up into one neat (and oh-so-handsome :D [this coming from a LILWL fan! :) :x]) package. It isn't so much what the two say to each other, but the way in which they say it. (Those of you have been kind enough to read my blogs in the past know non-verbal communication speaks volumes to me. This scene is no exception.)

Obi-wan: " You seem a little on edge."
Anakin: "Not at all."
Obi-wan: "I haven't felt you this tense since, since we fell into that nest of gundarks."
Anakin: "You fell into that nightmare, Master, and I rescued you. Remember?"
*pause*
Obi-wan: "Oh. Yes."
Obi-wan allows himself a quiet chuckle as he recalls that episode that is left to our imaginations; Anakin visibly relaxes, and a smile spreads across his young features. He gives his head a slight shake as if thinking that it is an all-too-common experience to have to remind his learned Master of the true facts that mark the moments in their lives. So forgetful is Obi-wan. ;) A warm look passes across Obi-wan's face as he recalls that harrowing episode, and, as well, that, without wanting to give anything away, he is well aware of why Anakin is a little on edge.

Through this simple exchange, we're given a glimpse into the history these two young men share. They've gotten themselves into a pickle or two over the course of time. They've saved each other's hides on more than one occasion. They've laughed. They've anguished. They've grown. Anakin from waif to padawan on the verge of becoming a full-fledged Jedi Knight. Obi-wan from padawan to Knight to Master. Each of them wears his mantle well.

In this scene, I can't help but compare myself to Obi-wan - probably because I am closer to his stage in the second chapter of the saga we hold dear than I am to Anakin's (but Anakin and his journey never are far from my thoughts - even though I am a LILWL :x). In this one scene, we see everything that Obi-wan is to Anakin, and the older Jedi is able to switch from one role to another so effortlessly. It's a pity Anakin doesn't understand all of Obi-wan's roles - some of which Obi-wan knows he soon will have to abandon. Anakin is almost old enough to shed his padawan "robes", and, once he does, Obi-wan knows his charge will be off on his own. Forget that Anakin is the Chosen One. Soon he'll solo, and Obi-wan won't be around to pull him out of any scrapes.

It's what I think about now that I am the parent of a new college student. My padawan's dreams are beginning to materialize into reality, and, while she has confidence that she will be all that she knows she can be, like Anakin, she experiences a bit of nervousness from time to time, and sees her mentor (in this case, me ;)) as someone who holds her back from doing everything she wants to do. Case in point . . . last week, we were talking about the end of the school year (I know second semester has just started, but we have to plan ahead because she is going to school so far away from home). I told her I would fly out to LA, help her pack up (which means I'll be doing most of the packing ;) since she'll be in the midst of finals). We'll then load up a rent-a-car, and head back to Wisconsin. "I can drive myself back, Mom," she told me. Inwardly, I laughed. Not guffawed, mind you. I just laughed. Inwardly, though. Like Obi-wan, I didn't want her to know my initial response. My padawan is a fine driver, and, while she is not afraid to head into new territory (much like her ol' mama! :D) as she expands her world, she has a hard time making it from one end of our county to another without getting . . . well, lost. As her parent, the thought of her driving solo halfway across the country, through the Tatooine desert and Geonosian mountains and Kasshyyyk forests and Naboo grassy plains makes me . . . well, rather wary. I admit it. She's never set out on an undertaking such as this before, and, while I don't want to hold her back from what she feels would be an incredible adventure (especially since I know that sometimes, in getting lost, we find our true selves), the thought of an 18-year-old young woman traveling by herself across unfamiliar terrain for such long stretches (she never has been behind the wheel for more than 30 minutes at a time. Imagine those 10-hour-driving days!) just does not sit very well with me. Thus, I think we'll compromise. I will let her plan the route home - and she'll have to do at least some of the driving!

This single scene in AOTC is what I think about when I look back on the March day in 2007 when my padawan got word that she was accepted into USC's film school. As she slowly opened the envelop that contained the school's easily identifiable logo in the return address, I could tell she was nervous. I was nervous myself. It was something she wanted so badly - to be accepted by this fine school just as Anakin was nervous about wanting Padmé to see him as a man, not as the little boy she knew 10 years earlier - and all I could do was hold my breath for a few moments before uttering, "You know, it wouldn't be the end of the world if you didn't get accepted. You put together an excellent application, but we both know how competitive and how hard it is to get into that school. You know they accept only about 50 applicants." (She applied to the production school. Like GL, she wants to be a director who happens to love editing. :D) I wanted to soften the blow in case the letter didn't contain the words she longed for so much. I could see the myriad of emotions wash over her features as she silently read the letter, and then she shared its contents with me. She got in!!!!! :D The strangers sitting on USC's film school board saw in her what I've seen and known all these years!!! :D (I still haven't come down from Cloud 9 - not because I want to live vicariously through my child, but because I am so happy for her, for what she has been able to accomplish . . . and it doesn't hurt that I know she's walking the same hallways that GL walked roughly 40 years ago! :D)

In the months that spanned from that moment to the moment I left her at school in August, I tried to impart the last lessons I thought were necessary to pass on to her before she truly was on her own. Her father and I had been preparing her for that moment for almost 18 years, but there still was so much more to teach her so she'd be ready to face life alone. I mean, I'd always be here, but, in reality, she'd have only herself on whom to depend. As I mull over everything I have told her, tried to teach her, I wonder if there was something - something important - I may have missed. I hope not. I wanted, too, for those last months to be months filled with happy memories on which she'd look back and smile. I know, though, that oftentimes I took a more serious approach to our time together, more serious than I really wanted. I think parents get more and more serious as the moment nears when they have to let their children go because life, while fun, truly is a serious matter. Parents want to make sure their children are prepared, and Obi-wan took his parental role very seriously.

A lot of fans criticize Obi-wan for the way he raised Anakin. "If only he did this . . ." "If only he had done that . . ." fans have lamented. Even I have played the "If only" card. Well, hindsight is 20/20 (which is not perfect vision, by the way! ;)), and one can't go back. All one can do is the best s/he can, and I think Obi-wan did a top-notch job! He loves Anakin very much, and, if you look closely, you can see it in his features in this one still moment in a galaxy far, far away. He doesn't utter those three words, but it's evident in the look on his face - from his Jedi intuition noticing Anakin's edginess to his semi-stern look on his face in the moments following their shared recollection to his warm chuckle at their shared joke. I am not trying to find fault with Anakin. I just see life through Obi-Wan's eyes in this particular instance. And, as the wise sage stated many years later to another young Jedi, "... you're going to find that many of the truths we cling to depend greatly on our own point of view."

I appreciate the fact that you've stuck with me all this while. I know this has been a rather lengthy entry. Who would have thought that a single still moment in a galaxy far, far away would spur one to such thoughts, but it has. It hasn't been the first time for me, and I doubt it will be the last! ;)

Have a wonderful day, and, as always,

MTFBWY :)
JMW

--------------------------------

If you'd care to read more entries that were inspired by a Star Wars moment in time, head on over to here. You won't be disappointed that you did. :D

leia19886
Some One get this big walking carpet out of my way
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 8:20 AM
I don't know what to say.
Your entry was beautiful!!!

Enjoy the drive with you daughter. :)
Jedi Master Mina
Jedi blogging, go back to your drinks!
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 8:56 AM
...and it doesn't hurt that I know she's walking the same hallways that GL walked roughly 40 years ago!

That sentence alone gave me chills. Just the thought of your daughter being able to walk the same halls as GL is awesome.

I am not trying to find fault with Anakin.

But there was a LOT of fault with Anakin. Hence his fall to the dark side. ;)

What a beautiful entry, my friend. I LOVE how you were able to intertwine your real life with the Still moment. Awesome. :)

A little green friend of ours would probably tell you..."you must learn to let go. Trust your instincts." ;)

Great Blog!!
jediprincess77
I Don't Know Where You Get Your Delusions...
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 8:59 AM
This was an incredible connection, JMW. Wow.

Sometimes it's difficult to know just what role Obi-Wan filled in Anakin's life. He mentions that Obi-Wan is the closest thing he has to a father, but Obi calls out (in that heart-wrenching line) that Anakin was his brother. Whatever you call it, they had a special relationship, beautifully compared here to that of you and your daughter.

Wonderfully done, JMW. :x Just beautiful.
amidalooine
The Emotional Galaxy
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 8:59 AM
There are tears in my eyes...again...JMW. For all that you are and all that I connect with in you. Great entry. :)
The Stooge
Star Wars Joke-A-Day
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 9:01 AM
Excellent defense of Obi-Wan... he sure has his share of detractors. But your vision of him -- as a parent -- is perfect. No matter how ideal the parent, a child will always, instinctively, want to be independent. That's why older Obi, with all his talk of perception and truth, really was the wisest guy in the whole saga.

And BTW, I'm fairly sure this scene was added to AOTC late in the shooting schedule. A reshoot, even. GL thought as you did... a moment was necessary to establish their bond, and their relationship, for what it really was: parental, but essentially good.
Granny-Wan
I Am NOT an Old Fossil!
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 9:15 AM
Great connection with Real Life! Having been a parent of a teenager, and having BEEN a difficult teenager, I feel for Obi-Wan throughout AOTC (I'm not THOSE feelings at the particular moment)....

And if you ARE a teenager...well, you know what your parents are like....

I love this moment in AOTC.... the closeness, the shared recollection of a disaster that they can now laugh about... something that only comes from a long and close relationship...

Much is lost because of Anakin's selfishness...

As for your daughter, I share JMM's feelings about walking the halls in GL's footsteps.... chills!
  zach starwalker
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 9:30 AM
I havent watched AOTC in a long long time.
nob01
Oil Bath Bubbles
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 10:19 AM
USC eh? Ask her to give me a job when she graduates ;)

A great entry, JMW - you were really able to give us an angle 'from a certain point of view' :)

Many people criticize GL writing, but I think this short scene just shows how skillful he is in providing years of backstory in a few short lines!!
MomOf2YoungPadawan
Mamadala's Lair
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 11:05 AM
First, let me say that your storytelling skills are not given enough justice here...although written incredibly well, I wish everyone else had the wonderful opportunity of watching you - and hearing you - tell your stories! My hubby even said you had him "hooked" as he listened from the next room :D I can totally "see" you narrating this blog, and I am grateful to be able to do so!! :x

*ahem* on to your blog...!

the much maligned Attack of the Clones WHY is that?!? Just because it's mainly a love story, perhaps?? This is my favorite PT movie! Strangely, my favorite PT movie is ESB. Something about transitioning...?

  ketal13
HanAnWan
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 11:06 AM
Wow! Superb entry JMW!
the best scene - that sets the stage for our understanding of Anakin's and Obi-wan's relationship
I absolutely agree!

In this scene, I can't help but compare myself to Obi-wan -
My two boys are still young, so I can't say that I can relate, but I can understand how you feel. I look forward the stage when my younglings begin to soar, but I dread it also, for sooo many reasons which are far too numerous to mention.

Excellent job!:)


MomOf2YoungPadawan
Mamadala's Lair
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 11:06 AM
I agree that this scene is so important in establishing the relationship between Obi and Ani - GL does it so well in such a short snippet of time. That's also why I like reading the books as well - it helps fill in the gaps and provides incredible amounts of backstory!

this coming from a LILWL fan! It must be a result of us all hanging out the other night - we're rubbing off on you ;)

Anakin is almost old enough to shed his padawan "robes", Don't even get me started on that :p :8}

Great job, Melinda! Thanks for sharing your personal stories! :x

JediPug1
Like My Father Before Me
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 1:15 PM
even though I am a LILWL

Thats' my girl... ;)

It's really interesting to note that this scene was added on as a last minute deal... good move on GL's part because it does set the stage for sooo much of what happens later.

Amazing entry here my dear friend! :x
  Sol Kassar
Ramblings from the Detention Center (Startled)
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 2:16 PM
This is fabulous! But it was all Obi-Wan's fault... :p
ewanandhaydenfan5
I Have You Now!
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 3:42 PM
Lovely blog, my dear!

I was glad that we saw the little bit of Obi's & Ani's relationship that we did..I wish we could have seen more.

This single scene in AOTC is what I think about when I look back on the March day in 2007 when my padawan got word that she was accepted into USC's film school.
I love that about the saga...so many relatable things in a sci-fi story!

I think Obi-wan did a top-notch job!
Me too. He might not have given Ani the emotional support he needed, but Obi gave everything that he knew how to give.
GalacticBabe
I Have a Bad Feeling About This!
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 3:50 PM
Aren't we all children, or at least young, at heart? Absolutely! As they say, age is just a number. And so what if our bodies don't function like they used to....our minds are still filled with the wonders of youth, and our wonderful Saga!:D

Just an amazing entry!! Loved it! And you!! :x
jedilily1026
Years Matter Not (Gone Crazy...Be Back Soon)
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 7:08 PM
Beautiful entry. Only from you can I expect this and about Anakin to boot...my favorite character.

Anakin visibly relaxes, and a smile spreads across his young features

I love the way his smile slowly crosses his face in this scene.

Once again...beautiful entry!!!
  Senator Soph-ia
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 7:25 PM
Lovely blog, JMW! I, too, am enthralled by the relationship between these two and think it's critically important to the saga. Establishing their bond was essential (in fact, I'd like to have seen a lot more of this part of the story -- but as you say, hindsight is 20/20!).

I love how you connected this to your daughter. I read it quite hungrily as it will only be 9 years (not nearly long enough!!) 'til I am in the same boat. I'll take all the words of wisdom I can get -- I found this quite insightful and very valuable!

I think you describe the scene beautifully and your parallel to your own life makes it very relevant. WELL DONE!
Granny-Wan
I Am NOT an Old Fossil!
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 8:48 PM
He might not have given Ani the emotional support he needed, but Obi gave everything that he knew how to give.

Obi-Wan trained Anakin the way Qui-Gon trained him, and he turned out to be a wonderful Jedi Knight.... if you'd read the "Jedi Apprentice" series, you know Obi-Wan was reckless, and egotistical as a youth...

Perhaps the flaw was in Anakin himself...
DJ Maul: Got Feet?
DJ Maul's Dancin' Cantina Party
date Posted: Jan 21, 2008 9:59 PM
excellent thoughts melinda.

so easy to nitpick Obi-Wans "failings" as a mentor...he did it himself too, afterwards...but there comes a point where the parent lets go and the child takes on the responsibility (if not always the mentality) of adulthood and makes their own path.

we all hope they choose the right ones, as your daughter seems to have.

we all FEAR they will choose the wrong ones, as Anakin did.

all we can REALLy do in the end is LOVE them, either way.

:) nice blog!
JediMelindaWolf
Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 5:03 AM
Enjoy the drive with you daughter.

It's always an adventure! (just like life) :D

A little green friend of ours would probably tell you...

And I try to listen to Yoda. I do. Really. I do. ;)

This was an incredible connection

Thank you, jp. When I saw this one still, my blog already was written! :D
  "shaggy" fett
A Bounty Hunter's Memoirs
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 10:33 AM
this blog gave me one of those chills down my spine is was so good. maybe its because i can relate to a lot of what you're saying (from the teenage point of view).

I don't want to hold her back from what she feels would be an incredible adventure (especially since I know that sometimes, in getting lost, we find our true selves),

this part especially got me. i've been planning on having one of those "get lost and find yourself" adventures since junior high. ever since then the desire to go out and explore the world has grown stronger and stronger. so strong in fact, that i'm taking a year off after i graduate high school this year to explore the country (i can't wait!).
  Smuggler Jedi
Hokey Religions and A Good Blaster at My Side
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 12:43 PM
Great blog entry. Not a scene i would have expected to be blogged on.

I'm impressed your daughter got into USC's film school. That is an incredible accomplishment.

Now that I think about this scene, and the one that follows, I'm reminded of my exprience with my three year old. As a parent, you go from calming (the elevator), to rebuking (when Obi-wan admonishes Anakin for not following his lead), to reassuring--all so quickly and frequently seemlessly.

Great choice.
  Jedi Arwen Skywalker
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 1:31 PM
Awesome, totally love this blog. :) Their relationship just makes me so sad, couse it was so strong, and then it just fell apart. :( I think the scene where Ani apologizes to Obi-wan, just before he leaves for Utuapa, and that is the last time they see each other as friends. :( *sniffle*
hansgirl3
Invoking the Squee
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 1:40 PM
Beautifully written, JMW!! :x

Through this simple exchange, we're given a glimpse into the history these two young men share.

That is so true!! It's awesome how much we learn from that scene, don't you think?

Have fun with your daughter and that looong drive back from LA! Exciting! I think I would have her do all of the driving to help her see that making it alone would really have not been the best idea... ;)
Jade Sabre777
A luminous being, I am...
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 3:56 PM
My eyes well up every time I see the pained expression on Obi-wan's face in that ROTS scene - and it's all because of these few seconds of film in AOTC.
Absolutely!

non-verbal communication speaks volumes to me.
Me too! Even if the time is limited, the non-verbal stuff can, like you said, speak volumes and make all the difference.

Anakin is almost old enough to shed his padawan "robes", and, once he does, Obi-wan knows his charge will be off on his own.
Which makes one wonder about Obi-Wan training another padawan......

Jade Sabre777
A luminous being, I am...
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 4:09 PM
A lot of fans criticize Obi-wan for the way he raised Anakin. "If only he did this . . ." "If only he had done that . . ." fans have lamented.
Guilty..... :8} But I suppose I must remember that no parent is perfect.

He loves Anakin very much, and, if you look closely, you can see it in his features in this one still moment in a galaxy far, far away.
So true!

Lovely entry, JMW!
JediMelindaWolf
Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 8:35 PM
There are tears in my eyes...

oh, ami, I hope someone made you laugh today!

GL thought as you did

what can I say . . . great minds . . . ;)

the shared recollection of a disaster that they can now laugh about

these kinds of moments bind people together. This makes O-W's and Anakin's relationship so bittersweet . . . at least to me.

I havent watched AOTC in a long long time

time for you to pop it in your vcr/dvd player, zs!
JediMelindaWolf
Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 8:42 PM
this short scene just shows how skillful he is in providing years of backstory in a few short lines

I'm with you, nobby! The dialogue never has bothered me. Like I said, the nonverbal communication adds volumes! :D

I wish everyone else had the wonderful opportunity of watching you - and hearing you - tell your stories!

You are too kind, my friend. Thank you. (and that was sweet of your husband to say what he did. :)) I am a storyteller at heart. :)

I look forward the stage when my younglings begin to soar

It's absolutely incredible!!! :D
JediMelindaWolf
Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 8:51 PM
Don't even get me started on that

I can see where you're going, ;) and, while I much prefer the feast my eyes beheld in ESB (that would be Luke :x on Dagobah :D :x), Anakin's appeal to some of you ;) is not lost on me. ;)

Thats' my girl...

we LILWL have to stick together!!! :D

But it was all Obi-Wan's fault...

:^O

Obi gave everything that he knew how to give.

Yes, he did. I just wish Anakin could have appreciated it.

And so what if our bodies don't function like they used to....

LOL :^O Oh, I can so relate! :D

I love the way his smile slowly crosses his face in this scene.

Me, too, jl! I think it's the most easy-going smile Anakin gives us. :D
JediMelindaWolf
Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 8:59 PM
I found this quite insightful and very valuable!

Thank you very much. :D Writing it brought back so many memories.

if you'd read the "Jedi Apprentice" series. . .

Interesting correlation, g-w. :) I'm with you. Obi-wan raised Anakin the way Qui-gon raised Obi-wan, and, since that was the case, an argument can be made that Anakin had the opportunity to turn out as well as his mentor. It's like I tell my daughters - every relationship is a two-way street. Part of the responsibility rests with the child to absorb the lessons being taught to him/her. That's why I never quite understand everyone criticizing Obi-wan so much. Obi-wan would have died for Anakin. If that isn't love, I don't know what is!
JediMelindaWolf
Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 9:06 PM
all we can REALLy do in the end is LOVE them, either way.

short and sweet and to the point, deej. :D

from the teenage point of view

:D

the desire to go out and explore the world has grown stronger and stronger

I say that, whenever you decide to begin your adventure, just begin it! You won't be sorry!

Not a scene i would have expected to be blogged on.

and therein lies the challenge. And it just goes to show that any scene in the saga has merit and meaning. :D

it was so strong, and then it just fell apart.

I know. It makes me sad, too. :(
JediMelindaWolf
Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
date Posted: Jan 22, 2008 9:13 PM
I would have her do all of the driving. . .

Oh, that is so tempting, hg! I know at the very least she'll be behind the wheel for rather lengthy stretches! We'll have to see how long she can last! ;)

Guilty.....

Aha! ;

But I suppose I must remember that no parent is perfect.

Are you sure? I tell my padawans that I am! ;) :^O :^O :^O (I couldn't resist! :8})

Lovely entry, JMW!

Thank you, JS! :)

MTFBWYAll :)
padmeskywalker77
Padme's Legacy
date Posted: Jan 23, 2008 8:53 PM
Sorry it took me to get to this. You did a wonderful job, my friend :x

This scene really is pivotal to the story and does speak volumes for the relationship between Obi-Wan and Anakin. I love how you were able to bring in your own family's trials into this...brings more of a personal touch to it.

Anakin is almost old enough to shed his padawan "robes" :x :p ;)

Sorry...couldn't help it :D

Again...wonderful job!! :x
viagoangel2
Were Anakin and Padme' really one?
date Posted: Jan 24, 2008 3:42 PM
Soon he'll solo, and Obi-wan won't be around to pull him out of any scrapes. Sorta like the phrase, "leaving the nest" ;) You can definitely see the joy and sadness, combined in Obi-Wan's handsome face. Proud, he sure is :x... skeptic of his padawans' future, Definitely! :| And what parent or guardian wouldn't be?:| That would simply be, unnatural]:) please excuse my sithly remark;) lol

Wonderful Entry, Milady :x
and Best Wishes to your padawan and Her Bright Future :x Yay!
  • Please log in to post comments