ROTS was beyond words. Amazing...
It definitely is up their with Empire if not the best. I'll have to watch it again to give a better opinion. Either an A or A-, or around 4.9 stars. (Can you sense my indecision).

First, good things about ROTS:
1. The portrayal of Anakin's fall is great, and really emotionally affects the reader.
2. Palpatine Rocks! Ian did a great job and I love his character.
3. Space Battle- Cool, a bit short, but quite explosive.
4. Lightsaber Duels- All were great, made an action-packed film.
5. Order 66- Almost made me cry, the music, and the jedi dying-a great part in the film
6. Grievous- Good, but more about him later
7. Yoda- AWESOME!!!!- one of the best parts of the movie, his duel with Sidious was great
8. End Montage- Great way to end series, tied everything together perfectly, made the film!
9. Temple Purge- Sad, could hardly watch it.

Some bad(often quite minor)
1. SBD's voice- couldn't they have made it lower? It really destroys its image.
2. Beginning of film- felt a bit rushed to get to Palpatine, made it seem too easy
3. Grievous- Why did they have him coughing? I know that in clone wars he got hurt by Mace, but it added nothing to the story but confusion
4. Padme- her role could have been written better, it seemed her importance was limited.

Other than those, the movie was GREAT! Definitely seeing it again. Further thoughts to come.