Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

I lost Tiree, lost Dutch!..or How I learned to stop worrying and love the Death Star.
by: gold5
date posted: Apr 16, 2008 4:04 PM  | 
updated: Apr 17, 2008 8:04 AM
I've never seen such devotion in a droid before!
Upon watching the birth of Vader in Revenge of the Sith the other day a thought occurred to me. A subject that though I had thought about, I had not seen this aspect of it previously. This being the relationship of Anakin and R2.

We all know how his relationship with Padme and with Obi-Wan ended. What we don't think of is how his other friendships ended. As I have said before, I love the novel in that it goes into that friendship much deeper than the movie. We got to know what our favorite astromech was saying as well as Anakin's thoughts on him.

Mutual Friendship & Loyalty
We get to see how close they are during the battle above Coruscant with Obi-Wan chastising Anakin about treating R2 like he was a person (meaning he showed too much attachment) and Anakin defending himself by saying R2 was to him a much better companion than most people. Anakin was genuinely concerned for R2's well being at this point. I would even go so far as to say that he felt love for R2-D2. The astromech in turn showed love and loyalty back to him. We do get to see in the film a condensed version of some of what goes on in the book with the elevator scene as he defends R2's efforts to Kenobi.

*On a side note, at this point it is interesting to look at the juxtaposition of RotS' two halves relationship wise. It reads like a story form of the Yin and Yang. At the beginning he cares about and shares many "moments" with these three figures and shows it openly. In the second half all of that is gone as he throws away all that should have truly mattered. All reject what he becomes. He's alienated and alone.*

The Change
Now back from my meandering mind's journey, let's look ahead to the moment after the purge when Anakin flies back to Padme's apartment. I have blogged this before but it needs repeating here. The book gives us the conversation between C-3PO & R2-D2. It is a touching aspect of a part of the story that as I said earlier is lacking in the film. R2 laments the change in Anakin. He knows something is wrong and is sad (and a bit scared) by what it might mean. The most touching and poignant part of the scene in the novelization is R2 telling 3PO that he (Anakin) doesn't talk to him anymore. This was for R2 the biggest sign of the change that suddenly happened in their relationship.

Shifting Loyalties
Next let's take another short leap forward to the arrival on Mustafar. As he had always done R2 hops out of the fighter only to have Anakin callously tells him to stay there. This act on Anakin's part was the final cut in the chord of the relationship. The next time we see R2 he is helping bring the limp body of Padme aboard her ship in an attempt to get her to safety. R2 abandons his one time friend to try to pick of the pieces of the wrecked life he (Anakin) left in his wake. His loyalty shifted to the future and the memory of the the Anakin he loved, left within the other "family" members. Luke was right when he said to Ben that he never saw such devotion in a droid before.

A Severed Self
Anakin was from the beginning a lover of all things mechanical. Droids were companions to a boy who knew and had very little else. This followed him to adulthood and was transferred onto R2 when Padme gave the astromech to him. From then to the fall they would fly together just as they had back on Naboo in TPM. He even adapted one of his Delta7 Jedi Fighters to accommodate R2-D2's full body.Switch to Episode IV. Vader is a loner his ship no longer uses the aid of an astromech. This ship while still showing a love of the the next best and greatest technology is to me a symbol of the loss of his old friendship with R2 and other droids. He then goes on to shoot unknowingly the droid he had known so well. Solidifying his detachment. In fact there is no evidence of any interaction with any droids in the OT. Droids became not beings but tools that he no longer needed or felt kinship to. Vader in essence severed all elements of what he had and still could have been.

Another Change
Something else in connection to this tale is that Obi-Wan (whether he recognizes him or not) greets R2 in the Tatooine dessert as his "little friend". A big change from Kenobi of the PT who was at that time the one who considered droids as just tools. In his exile he must have found the value of all beings within the Force, mechanical & living. Who can deny that the Force was working through R2 and his devotion to the Skywalkers to bring all involved together at last. To right what had all gone wrong in his life becoming the companion of the son of Anakin.


***On Another side note*****I also want to point out another thing I noticed in reference to R2. In the escape of the Falcon at the end of ESB, he is working on the hyperdrive since he was the only one who knew what the Empire had done. C-3PO tells him to let Chewbacca do it and that he doesn't know how to fix a hyperdrive. Besides the fact that this was stupid on part of 3PO anyway considering this is one of an astromech's primary functions. It is funny to know that our introduction to R2-D2 in sequential time of the GFFA is him fixing a hyperdrive and assisting the escape of another group of fugitives. I couldn't help when viewing ESB on Spike noticing the comparitive scenes. ******


I'll catch you all later. I need to start my drive home. My wife and little girl are now in Memphis for a week so it's not much to look forward to in going home. It'll be a bit lonely, so I'll probably go to bed early as well. ... Or not . We'll see.

-Gold5

nob01
Oil Bath Bubbles
date Posted: Apr 16, 2008 5:34 PM
Who can deny that the Force was working through R2
Ah, but the light side, or the dark....?

You know my feelings on this :)

A great blog, Gold5 - I must confess I had never considered Vader shooting R2 in the trench to be so poignant.
MissPadme
Miss Padme's Naboo Love Nest
date Posted: Apr 16, 2008 6:40 PM
Very interesting. Artoo wants so desperately in ANH for Luke to like him and now we know why ;).
leia19886
Some One get this big walking carpet out of my way
date Posted: Apr 16, 2008 7:16 PM
Interseting! R2 was so loyal.
You can see that in ANH when R2 goes looking for Obi-Wan.
Darth_Hiram
A Journey into The Force
date Posted: Apr 16, 2008 8:50 PM
Excellent blog. R2 is such a pivotal character in the entire saga, and you point out his relationship with the Skywalker family perfectly. He definitely played a big role in Anakin's, Luke's and also Leia's lives.
  PrincessAngel39
date Posted: Apr 17, 2008 2:54 AM
Very nice blog. I have also read the book you are quoting, but I have never realized before that R2 switches to follow Padmé and Obi-wan together with his friend 3PO instead of remaining with Anakin/Vader. Thank you to show this. He remains loyal to his former master, Padmé, and to the formerly Anakin's beloved ones, probably because of the way Anakin is behaving towards him and towards Padmé. He remains loyal to Anakin protecting and helping his family but rejects serving Vader. (cont'd)
  PrincessAngel39
date Posted: Apr 17, 2008 2:55 AM
As we also know, R2's memory was not wiped out, so he is perfectly aware of who is Leia looking for, his old friend Obi-Wan Kenobi, and he probably recognizes the Skywalker family name in Luke, so he is aware whom he is serving, so he is still loyal to Padmé and Anaking serving their son.
Regarding Obi-Wan, yes, he looks much more friendly to R2 in ANH, and no doubt he recognizes him clearly when he displays Leia's message.
  PrincessAngel39
date Posted: Apr 17, 2008 3:53 AM
And a further question: would Anakin regret R2 and 3PO's loss when he realized that R2 was not with him any more and that probably he would never see again 3PO, who was his creation?
Probably he would drown their memory in the same lava pit where he left most of his body and all his former life ....
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Apr 17, 2008 8:12 AM
Great blog!

It is funny to know that our introduction to R2-D2 in sequential time of the GFFA is him fixing a hyperdrive and assisting the escape of another group of fugitives.

Wow - I never made that connection, very cool!
gold5
I lost Tiree, lost Dutch!..or How I learned to stop worrying and love the Death Star.
date Posted: Apr 17, 2008 8:12 AM
Ha! :^O I knew you would show up Nob01.

Of course Vader wasn't trying to shoot the R2 unit of the X-wing in front of him but trying to destroy the whole ship. That doesn't change that part as symbolic none the less.

Does anyone else notice that R2 gets fried in every movie if the OT. No respect at all I tell you.
gold5
I lost Tiree, lost Dutch!..or How I learned to stop worrying and love the Death Star.
date Posted: Apr 17, 2008 8:22 AM
Artoo wants so desperately in ANH for Luke

He is very needy for a droid, but then I think it was his loyalty kicking in as well as finally belonging again and not being just another droid.

when R2 goes looking for Obi-Wan

He knew his duty.

R2 is such a pivotal character

He has always been my favorite character
gold5
I lost Tiree, lost Dutch!..or How I learned to stop worrying and love the Death Star.
date Posted: Apr 17, 2008 8:30 AM
probably because of the way Anakin is behaving towards him and towards Padmé

It was confusing to him but he knew something was happening/changing.

he is still loyal to Padmé and Anakin

Exactly! He may not of understood what had happened fully but he knew how he allegiance could be serve the well being of those he felt he belonged.

would Anakin regret R2 and 3PO's loss

I think by then he was so self absorbed that they did not matter and probably gave no thought to them afterward. Plus like you said the soul that would have cared at all was lost with the rest of him on Mustafar.
gold5
I lost Tiree, lost Dutch!..or How I learned to stop worrying and love the Death Star.
date Posted: Apr 17, 2008 8:34 AM
Wow - I never made that connection, very cool!

Neither had I and here I thought I had noticed all aspects of the movies by now.;)
I wonder if Lucas had this intent with that scene in TPM connecting to the ESB scene.
Granny-Wan
I Am NOT an Old Fossil!
date Posted: Apr 17, 2008 10:09 AM
Poor Artoo, he was probably as heartbroken as Obi-Wan and Padme... but who could he tell? Not Threepio, he had his mind wiped... Artoo was as wise as a Jedi to keep his secrets to himself...

I just started leafing through "Jedi v Sith, the Essential Guide to the Force" and I love it how they have recovered recordings from R2-D2 to fill in their history, it's a nice touch!

The Stooge
Star Wars Joke-A-Day
date Posted: Apr 17, 2008 4:42 PM
I'm with ya... there's definitely a strange dichotomy between Anakin's love of technology and how Vader really didn't care for it. (Force chokes aside, he was pretty hands on as Sith Lord.) Maybe Vader just hated what he had become, and took his frustration out on any technological terrors he came across.

And I'm not sure R2 fixed a hyperdrive in his intro during TPM. I believe it was the shield generator... after all, the botched hyperdrive is why they had to land on Tatooine in the first place.
gold5
I lost Tiree, lost Dutch!..or How I learned to stop worrying and love the Death Star.
date Posted: Apr 17, 2008 8:52 PM
I believe it was the shield generator

Oh yeah...well........aren't you just all smart with your...facts & stuff!:p

I'm going to have to look at that again. Though not right now since our only DVD player is a portable one which Abby has with her in Memphis at the moment. It comes on Sike again this weekend doesn't it? Oh wait duh! I have that one on VHS too *smacks self in forehead* Stil it will have to wait. Too tired now.
  PrincessAngel39
date Posted: Apr 21, 2008 8:31 AM
I believe The Stooge is right, R2 succeeds to fix the shield generator, not the hyperdrive.
Jade Sabre777
A luminous being, I am...
date Posted: Apr 22, 2008 5:37 PM
:_| :_| :_|

R2 abandons his one time friend to try to pick of the pieces of the wrecked life he (Anakin) left in his wake. His loyalty shifted to the future and the memory of the the Anakin he loved, left within the other "family" members.
A beautiful statement. :x R2 truly is an amazing droid. :)

Droids became not beings but tools that he no longer needed or felt kinship to.
So true.

Amazing entry, Gold5! I feel so sorry for R2 now! (And so mad at Anakin!)
  • Please log in to post comments