Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Jedi Wampa's Playhouse
date posted: Feb 27, 2007 7:58 PM  |  updated: Feb 27, 2007 7:59 PM
Anakin: powerful Force user, or more of a victim than we thought?
Ok, so I was kicking back and reading the latest LotF book (which will remain nameless, as I think I got it early) and it got me thinking. In the books, there's a nasty Sith who can project thoughts to others. So here we go. Keep all hands and feet inside the vehicle, and hang on for the ride.

Everyone presumes Anakin Skywalker was such a powerful Force user that, even without focusing, he could get random visions of the future (like, say, in dreams). These visions gave him goals that he fought for, to the point of driving himself to the edge of insanity and over to the dark side of the Force. These visions led to the fall that would cast the galaxy into the dark for decades.

But were they truly visions of the future?

After following the career of Jedi Skywalker with great interest, Palpatine had become a close friend and advisor to the young man. During this time, it's very likely that Anakin would have shared his thoughts, worries, fears, and ambitions.

Now, years later, Anakin gets a vision of his mother, in trouble, being hurt, and near death. The one strong, emotional link to his past life, the main reason that Yoda didn't want him trained, and suddenly he has a vision that makes him run off with no plan and eventually leads to one of his first major expressions of the Dark Side.

A few years later, he gets yet another vision, this time of his one solid touchstone to the future - his wife and children, his family - in danger of dying. Again, he runs off with little in the way of goal other than "Save Padmé" and ends up completing his fall and becoming the newest Dark Lord of the Sith.

So, what if they weren't visions? What if they were projections? What if Palpatine, the True Lord of the Dance....er....Sith, knowing Anakins fears and weaknesses, projected these images, knowing exactly what buttons to push to make the youngster loose all sense of right and wrong? Palpatine manipulated the Senate, the courts, his 'friends,' pretty much the entire galaxy. Why should Anakin, the powerful force that Palpatine desperately wanted as his muscle, be an exception?

I present for your consideration that he was not an exception. I suggest that the 'nightmare visions' that led Anakin to his fall were actually planted there by Lord Sidious, soon-to-be-Emperor Palpatine. The visions were planted as dreams, and we exactly the right thing to make Anakin act recklessly, but predictably to one who knew his innermost thoughts.







Or maybe it was a bad glass of blue milk, leading to indigestion....

gencrs
Technical Manuals from The GFFA
date Posted: Feb 27, 2007 8:23 PM
Very interesting idea. I don't know if you've read the novelization of ROTS, but there is a part where Palpatine tells Anakin that a young Jedi was seen leaving Padme's apartment early in the morning. I believe that this was before the scene in the movie where Anakin has a vision of Obi-Wan talking to Padme when she dies. The fact that Palp's suggested there was a secret relationship would be a cause Anakin to "see" Kenobi in his vision.

Good blog.
  eumesmo1
Does Leia really remember Padmé?
date Posted: Feb 28, 2007 2:35 AM
But if those dreams were just implanted images in Anakin's mind then how can we explain that they were fullfield? And in the first dream of his mother he saw her in pain, and she was actually in pain so he just felt that pain, it was nothing that was going to happen it already happened.
The Stooge
Star Wars Joke-A-Day
date Posted: Feb 28, 2007 7:19 AM
What if Palpatine, the True Lord of the Dance....er....Sith

:^O Curse you and your funnies!
  Master Deireanach
date Posted: Feb 28, 2007 8:34 AM
I love your line of thinking here, and after reading the ROTS and Dark Lord novels, it makes perfect sense. Sidious was always manipulating Anakin, he even knew he would lose to Obiwan on Mustafar. So it wouldn't be a strecth to say he implanted those visions in Anakin's dreams.
  Master Deireanach
date Posted: Feb 28, 2007 8:36 AM
eumesmo1

as for why it came true, it was a self fulfilling prophecy. If you think about an outcome too much and you truly believe that is what's going to happen then you force it to come true.
  Fish1941
date Posted: Feb 28, 2007 9:11 AM
I have to agree with eumesmo1. This doesn't explain how Anakin was able to sense Shmi's situation over a period of a month. And I also find it hard to accept that all of Anakin's visions came from Palpatine. Yes, the latter is capable of making planting highly suggestible ideas to Anakin, without use of telepathy. But I still believe that his visions came solely from Anakin.
  Saba8
date Posted: Feb 28, 2007 3:55 PM
I think that Anakin really dreamed about his mother's pain because I read somewhere that Shmi was Force-sencative. And Anakin was very close to his mother and she wanting to see her son for one last time she might have reached out to him.

But if Sid implanted the dream about Padme I wouldn't put it past him, not in a hundred Zillion years.

Great thought!
  Master Deireanach
date Posted: Mar 01, 2007 6:29 AM
Exactly Saba8

Anakins visions of Shmi were his own, Anakin told Sidious how he reacted to his mothers death. This would lead Sidious to say hmm if I can make Anakin feal that Padme is in the same danger as his mother was, it will lead Anakin further down the dark path.
  Aurin_Starkiller
date Posted: Mar 01, 2007 1:32 PM
"Or maybe it was a bad glass of blue milk, leading to indigestion...."

I think this theory makes the most sense... ;)

"because I read somewhere that Shmi was Force-sensitive"

It says in the TPM novelization that she is slightly, but not enough to explain the extreme amounts of midichlorians present in her son.

God Bless,

May the Force grant you wisdom...
  • Please log in to post comments