Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

A Journey into The Force
date posted: Apr 05, 2008 12:34 AM  |  updated: Apr 05, 2008 8:01 AM
Unlimited power
I got to thinking about Palpatine after my wife and I watched the movie Sicko, by Michael Moore. If you've seen the movie, it's about the downfalls of the American health care system, and the horrors its wrought upon some families and individuals through beaurocratic red tape. And he compares the system to other countries and their health care systems, such as what we have here in Canada (yes, I'm Canadian), in Britain, in France, and even on American soil in Guantanamo Bay. It's a detailed look into what ails the current system and how other countries have developed their system over time.

And in one scene, he interviews a former British Member of Parliament, I believe, who gives his insight into what he thinks holds a population in check with some governments ... fear and demoralization. If the population is frightened and have lost their sense of what the right thing to do is, they will succumb to what the authourity tells them to do. In the case of U.S. citizens and their right to proper health care, they are at the mercy of government and large pharmeceutical corporations and insurance companies ... controlling the fear over what can be afforded, and at what cost to health.

And I think of Palpatine's Empire. He controlled the galaxy through fear, and through frightening people into bending to his will. Anyone who crossed him would suffer at either his hands or at Vader's. He was very much in control and would use fear as a tactic. Even Tarkin said that fear would keep systems in line ... fear of the battle station, but in reality, fear of the Empire and what could happen if one were to go against the grain and challenge that authority. And I think Palpatine even kept Vader in check through fear ... fear of abandonment, fear of lonlieness, fear of ending Vader's own life if he were to fail Palpatine (such as during Luke and Vader's fight on DSII ... encouraging Luke to strike down Vader). And Palpatine even got the Republic on his side in the PT through fear ... convincing the population to hand him political powers to see the situation through to the end. And in the end, he convinced them that the Jedi were the bad guys and that they were to be feared and needed to be finished ... another tactic of fear-mongering.

And of course Palpatine was a demoralizing factor in the galaxy. He made alien races a target and only viewed his Empire as the true authority in the galaxy. The planets and people he oppressed would eventually rise up in the form of rebellion to the demoralizing conditions he brought to the galaxy. They couldn't stand his authority for one minute longer and felt something had to be done ... to get rid of the source of the fear and demoralization that plagued them all. But in his mind, he thought all was under control ... that he was in charge due to his fear tactics and brutal hand. He couldn't see that underneath the fear and oppression beat a heart of bravery and passion. It was a glass house he lived in, and one which easily was shattered once the first rock was thrown ... the one Luke cast and which reverberated to all the galaxy. All the citizens of the galaxy wanted the same thing and when Luke and Anakin shattered Palpatine's fear and demoralization, all could rejoice in the good fortune.

So Michael Moore's movie about health care doesn't ring that far off from the state of the galaxy during Palpatine's time. Fear kept the population doing as he said, but was demoralizing at the same time. And a small band of Rebels and a guy with a very big heart and courage were all it took to make things right.

nob01
Oil Bath Bubbles
date Posted: Apr 05, 2008 9:53 AM
It's no coincidence that so many reviewers (and fans) spotted the parallels between the crumbling Republic and the current government.
As for instilling fear into the populace, that is the easiest way to control them (is this a democratic or totalitarian state?), and the media plays a big part in this too.
The cultivation theory of communication suggests that people who learn about the world through TV end up with a skewed perspective, and develop what's known as 'mean world syndrome' - which makes it easier for the govt. to frighten and control them.

Blimey, is it Saturday morning?
Vil Obasio
Trash Compactor
date Posted: Apr 05, 2008 11:43 AM
controlling the fear over what can be afforded, and at what cost to health.


First of all, let me say that I have not seen a traditional doctor in over 6 years, and not because it's too expensive. I don't trust pharmeceutical companies and their medication, and "modern medicine" causes as many problems as it cures. I've gone the natural medicinal route, using things like acupuncture (scary, I know, but it works) and chiropractic care, along with simple things like eating right and exercising.

(cont.)
Vil Obasio
Trash Compactor
date Posted: Apr 05, 2008 11:46 AM
It's obvious you have no love of America's government or the way they run things, and I'm not going to try and change your mind; we are all entitled to our opinions, be they wrong or right. But in the arena of healthcare, I think America's biggest problem is not the government, but the American people themselves. Look at the obesity rates in our country, or the cancer rates. People's number one enemy to their health is their own bad habits. A significant portion of the average American's diet consists of foods that contain high levels of cancer-causing perservatives, and it's been known for years.

(cont.)
Vil Obasio
Trash Compactor
date Posted: Apr 05, 2008 11:49 AM
Just like smoking cigarettes, the cumultive effects of things like aspartame build up in your system and cause cancer in even small children.

Yes, healthcare is expensive, and our system needs improvement. But the number one person who is responsible for your health is you, and movies like Sicko that rail against the big government for keeping everyone sick doesn't really change the fact that most people are simply not willing to take their own well-being into their own hands.

(cont.)
Vil Obasio
Trash Compactor
date Posted: Apr 05, 2008 11:51 AM
Modern healthcare is inefficient and many people cannot recieve the care they need, it's true. But that will always be the case, regardless of what system we choose.

Does the American government want people to suffer so they can stay in power, as you seem to be implying? As an American myself, I disagree with such a claim.

Good blog, well-written.
amidalooine
The Emotional Galaxy
date Posted: Apr 05, 2008 12:28 PM
I hope you don't mind, DH, but I've written my own blog entry to comment on yours.

As always, you are an excellent writer, and you make me think. Thank you!
leia19886
Some One get this big walking carpet out of my way
date Posted: Apr 05, 2008 1:45 PM
It's my opinion the Michael Moore has tunnel vision when it comes to our country and what is good for it. Yes there are problems, but I've not personally heard Mr. Moore offer
any solutions. All I have ever heard him say is the problems.
No, I've not seen the movie Sicko.


Thanks again for the well wishes concerning my sister.
The service for her son will be Monday.
Leia
Darth_Hiram
A Journey into The Force
date Posted: Apr 05, 2008 2:00 PM
and the media plays a big part in this too.
Very true, Nobby. And I hadn't thought too much on the subject until I saw the movie. Not that I'm a big Michael Moore fan, I just thought the points raised were worth discussing.

It's obvious you have no love of America's government or the way they run things
No, I don't feel that way towards American government ... I am just recognizing the differences in different society's systems. As I mentioned, I'm not a huge Moore fan, I just thought it a topic to discuss. Moreso, I wanted to draw upon the Star Wars galaxy!
Darth_Hiram
A Journey into The Force
date Posted: Apr 05, 2008 2:08 PM
Does the American government want people to suffer so they can stay in power, as you seem to be implying?
Again, I'm not implying that, or making any claims ... just trying to draw parallels to SW, and the way the movie was presented. Thanks for commeting, Vil!

I hope you don't mind, DH, but I've written my own blog entry to comment on yours.
Of course I don't mind, Ami! I look forward to reading it!

but I've not personally heard Mr. Moore offer
any solutions.

True, leia. Perhaps that needs to be his next project!
And my thoughts will be with you for Monday.
Vil Obasio
Trash Compactor
date Posted: Apr 05, 2008 4:10 PM
Again, I'm not implying that, or making any claims ... just trying to draw parallels to SW, and the way the movie was presented.

Ah, I guess I misunderstood then. I thought you were drawing parallels between America and the Empire. :^O
Darth_Hiram
A Journey into The Force
date Posted: Apr 05, 2008 7:42 PM
I thought you were drawing parallels between America and the Empire
No worries! The only point I was trying to cover is the topic that the British MP raised ... that populations have, in the past in whichever country, have been held in check through fear and demoralizing circumstances. And I found in SW that this is how Palpatine ruled the galaxy. And of course, the Moore movie was still fresh in my mind, so that's what I used as my basis.
The Stooge
Star Wars Joke-A-Day
date Posted: Apr 06, 2008 12:50 AM
Meh, until someone actually seizes power in this country and refuses to let go (happens allllllllllllll over the world, yet everybody ignores that, they're too concerned about America losing its precious freedoms), I aint worrying. :)
Darth_Hiram
A Journey into The Force
date Posted: Apr 06, 2008 9:43 PM
Good point Stooge!
padmeskywalker77
Padme's Legacy
date Posted: Apr 07, 2008 10:42 PM
Although I have not see Moore's "documentary," it appears that you have made some great parallels.

I am in health care (not going to get into that argument ;) ), and I have seen what happens with the insurance companies (the Emperor) and the people (everyone else)...not always a "pretty" sight. The fact that these things indeed are happening just doesn't always make sense to me.

Just as the Empire instilled fear throughout the galaxy, so does the ways of modern governments in our own world (and no thanks to those "reporters" like Moore who just materialize on the sensationalism).

As usual, a great entry...giving me something to think about :)
JediMelindaWolf
Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
date Posted: Apr 09, 2008 10:11 AM
Wow, dh. What a blog! Sure got me thinking. I read it first last night, mulled it over some, and finally am back to comment.


I have to admit that I have not seen "Sicko." Some day, I hope to. (you know - there just are so many hours in a day.) From the little I know about the docufilm, it certainly gives one quite a bit of food for thought.

Generally speaking, I have to say that there always are two (usually more) sides to every story. That, coupled with the fact that we do not live in a perfect society/world, almost every aspect of life is open to many different interpretations.

(cont. . .)
JediMelindaWolf
Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
date Posted: Apr 09, 2008 10:20 AM
(cont. . .)

As my husband says, one can get statistics to say anything you want them to - just depends on how you interpret them.

I, a former journalist, say, "always consider the source." (consider, too, that much what purports itself to be news these days actually is not news. It merely is posturing under the guise of news.)


And don't forget - while some try to keep the locals in line through fear, many of us aren't buying it. We work for change. As long as at least some of us keep that idea alive, there is hope. (I mean this in a general sense.)

Enjoyed your blog. :)

MTFBWY :)
Darth_Hiram
A Journey into The Force
date Posted: Apr 11, 2008 10:57 PM
The fact that these things indeed are happening just doesn't always make sense to me.
Indeed ... who knows what happens behind the scenes, but it just draws attention to the fact that some people really need help. Thanks for commenting!

As long as at least some of us keep that idea alive, there is hope.
I agree, JMW! I think that is why I love ANH so much ... it really encourages hope and victory in tough times ... we can succeed at anything we put our minds to.
Thanks for coming back to comment!



  • Please log in to post comments