Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Smugglers Rants
date posted: Oct 02, 2005 3:28 AM
Sacrifices
In Revenge of the Sith we see Luke delivered into the caring hands of Owen and Beru, who agree to raise Luke as their own in the harsh environs of Tatooine.
We see Leia taken by Bail Organa, where she is to be raised as a Princess on the lavish world of Alderaan.
Leia becomes a member of the Imperial Senate, following, unknowingly, in the footsteps of her mother by becoming an important political figure at a tender age and fighting for the rights and beliefs of her homeworld in an effort to restore the Republic.
Like Anakin, Luke leads a simple, hard life, wishing for adventure but not knowing how to achieve it. Unlike his secret sister, he feels his life has taken a detour into a cul-de-sac.
Until the chance to leave Tatooine arises in the form of Ben Kenobi, who tells Luke of his heritage (albeit "from a certain point of view") and gives young Luke the chance to see those distant stars for himself and journey with him to Alderaan.
But Luke declines.
The disappointment and surprise is evident by Bens almost petulant reaction. He knows that, in order to restore balance to not only the Force but to the galaxy, that he needs the son of Anakin Skywalker by his side. But Luke's not paying ball. Suddenly he shrinks back, worries about Owen and Beru and merely offers to take Ben "as far as Anchorhead."
So, is it unreasonable to think that when the Empire attack the Homestead, killing Beru and Owen in the process, that Ben would have forseen this?
That their death, as abhorent a thought it may be, was a means to an end - to ignite Luke's lust for adventure and, dare I say it, revenge?
Luke put two and two together and realised the danger Owen and Beru were in, and raced to the Homestead at full burn. But there was no reason for him to see their charred bodies
Was there?
Wasn't that the moment, right where we'd watched him stare at Tatoo 1 and 2 wishing for a life away from Tatooine, when he saw there was nothing left for him there? With his aunt and uncle, at least he had some kind of purpose, a safety net to fall back on. With them gone, Tatooine held nothing for him.
Don't you think Ben knew that too?
So, in a manner of speaking, you could say that Ben sacrificed Owen and Beru to bring the son of the Chosen One into play.
"From a certain point of view."

  darthyoda340
date Posted: Oct 02, 2005 7:21 AM
Yeh Obi Wan Was Behind It All Getting Luke To Come 2 Him And Then Getting The Droids To Kill Owen And Beru They Served There Purpose In This Tale
  jediknight2210
Where did you dig up that old fossil?
date Posted: Oct 02, 2005 9:21 AM

Remember, Ben also said "You should do what you feel is right of course" He was not forcing him because that would be morally wrong, "Ben was a great man"
janlomona
Smugglers Rants
date Posted: Oct 02, 2005 9:46 AM
Don't forget, it was Luke that said "Ben is a great man." - not the most objective view in the galaxy. Luke idolised Kenobi.
We know from past situations that the Jedi aren't above manipulating situations to their own ends. Qui-Gon for instance. Just watch him waving his hands around in Otoh Gunga, as well as trying it on with Watto and changing the roll of the chance cube. Ben often uses his Jedi Mind Trick (on Sleasebag and the Stormtrooper).
janlomona
Smugglers Rants
date Posted: Oct 02, 2005 9:48 AM
What I'm saying is, that for the cause of the greater good, Ben wouldn't be morally constrained by `allowing' Owen and Beru to die. Restoring the Jedi Order would take precedence over practically everything else. They waited 22 years until Luke went to Yoda, why would something as relatively trivial as allowing Luke to see their bodies stop him?
Ben, like Yoda, was driven for a cause. Luke made it clear that he didn't want to leave Tatooine. The death of his guardians changed this, and seeing their bodies sealed the deal. And I believe Ben knew exactly what he was doing, every step of the way.
  • Please log in to post comments