Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Smugglers Rants
date posted: Dec 05, 2005 11:51 AM
Who's Crime is it Anyway?
We're almost at the end of the Star Wars prequel trilogy. We've witnessed the return of the Sith, the decline of the Republic, the arrival of the Chosen One, the faultering Jedi and Order 66.
Chancellor Palpatine stands in the midst of the Senate chamber and tells of the attempt on his life, the Jedi plot to overthrow the Republic and his intention to hunt down the remaining Jedi Knights.
But what do the assembled Senators from a thousand far-flung star systems do in reaction to this devastating news?
They applaud. Wildly.

But should we be surprised by this?

"For a thousand generations the Jedi Knights were the guardians of peace and justice in the old Republic", or so Ben Kenobi told us. They meted out summary justice, were brought in to planetary disputes, were able to settle problems without invitiation or recourse for their actions. They used their mind control powers to influence the weak-minded, answered to no-one and believed themselves to be `better' than the general poplace.

That could be a common belief held by an average citizen of the Republic. The Jedi thought themselves superior, and in many ways they were, with their connection to the Force. But it's possible many saw them as not only the strong arm of the Republic, but as a faction in itself.
And perhaps some within the Republic saw them as a threat too.

Being a wily politician, Palpatine sensed this groundswell of negative feeling towards the Jedi. Indeed, it was this negativity that he used to turn the Republic and the citizens of the galaxy against the Jedi. But the Jedi were no politicians. They didn't trust politicians, as Kenobi pointed out on more than one occasion, They didn't see the turn of the tide against them until it was too late. Their "arrogance blinded them", to paraphrase Palpatine.

So when Palpatine stated his intention to wipe out the Jedi, were the Senate merely hoodwinked into following and believing what he was saying, or was there more to it than that? After all, he had played the Separatists against the Republic, built the Jedi up to be heroes before engineering their `betrayal', and everyone followed blindly.
Was the removal of the Jedi something that many Senate members secretly longed for?
Certainly they wouldn't have expected to replace the Jedi with a Sith overlord, or the kind of Empire they ultimately wound up with, but at the time of Revenge of the Sith, with a weak and seemingly corrupt Republic about to crumble, and the Jedi exposed as traitors, is it surprising that they turned on their Jedi protectors?

It seems an obvious question - the facts are right there on screen, but go deeper and you could begin to see a line of events that doomed the Jedi a long time before the prequels.

"Jedi poodu!" - Attack of the Clones

  yodafueva
Journal of a mad SW and HP fan
date Posted: Dec 05, 2005 11:57 AM
well in jedi quest Bog Divian tries to get rid of jedi interference, but the senate was corrupted most senators were really with palpy and some would believe anything the Chancelor said
  Kenobi-fan
The Jundland Wastes Journal
date Posted: Dec 05, 2005 12:09 PM
Your blog goes to the heart of the Jedi problem. Like life in general, things change. You either adapt, or die like the dinosaurs. I'm sure life for the average Republic citizen changed much over the last 1000-years. However, it would appear the Jedi didn't, making them seem elitist and anachronistic - a dangerous thing in times of change. Palpatine's speech, like his monologue to Anakin about the powers of the DS to save Padme, takes advantage of the public's concerns and elevates them to disproportionate heights.
  Grand Admiral Veers0
date Posted: Dec 05, 2005 1:44 PM
It was not just the superior feelings that many citizens felt the Jedi had against them, but their massive failures as protectors.
Sora Bulg, Depa Billaba, Quinlan Vos, Aayla Secura, these were just a few of the Jedi who turned from the Jedi and became enemies of the Republc. Hardly military leaders, the Jedi suffered numerous blunders against the the Separatists and cost the lives of many. Certainly, there were those like Skywalker and Kenobi who ensured victory and saved lives, but they were in the vast minority. Add to the fact that the Jedi practiced an "ancient religion" and "sorceror's ways" and you have a recipe for unrelenting hatred or at least mistrust.
  mubos
date Posted: Dec 05, 2005 2:22 PM
the republic loved the jedi no question about it, they were seen as heros, saviours and protectors. untill they screwed up of corse, then they were seen as aragant, foolish and far too overconfidant. to quote Green Goblin in spider-man "what they love more is to see a hero fail, see them fall!" or Flanders in the simpsons "my prayers where with you homer, but part of me wanted to see ya get splatered" it is for this very reason that most didnt mind when they had been taken from the galaxy.

"i was a jedi night of the old republic, before the empire!"
- obi-wan "Ben" Kenobi, a New Hope
  Lord Zeltrec
date Posted: Dec 05, 2005 2:53 PM
By the way can someone please make me a blog for me i will be very happy i have posted this on a lot of bllogs so
What other sith powers are there besides Force lightning and force choke?
]:) ?:|
  Darth Kevinmhk
date Posted: Dec 05, 2005 8:23 PM
Depa Billaba turned to dark side, but not really an enemy of the Republic.

Vos redeemed himself and continue to serve as General till EP3.

And when did Aayla Secura turned? I really don't know!
  Elflord_99
date Posted: Dec 06, 2005 11:51 AM
In the novel, the arrest of Palpatine was broadcasted on the Holocam. Of course the Holocam was doctored to make the arrest look like an assasination and coup of the Republic. Even in a far away galaxy, TV has great influence over the public.
  Darth Kevinmhk
date Posted: Dec 07, 2005 5:28 AM
In the novel, Elflord, Palpatine's arrest was an audio only record.
Palpatine end the recording himself after the sound he needed was recorded.
  Elflord_99
date Posted: Dec 07, 2005 6:50 AM
DK - Thanks for the clarity, I think I'm gonna read that book again.
  • Please log in to post comments