Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Smugglers Rants
date posted: Aug 15, 2007 8:49 AM
Necessary Evil
My good lady wife Frans Latka posted a blog the other day that really got me thinking. While there are plenty of Jedi who seem to fall to the dark side, or the ways of the sith, are there any journeys in the other direction?

I thought about it and - as far as my knowledge of the EU goes - there aren't any.

Perhaps Anakin counts, she asked, but I've been thinking about that one.

Anakin was a Jedi - the Chosen One - who became a sith by necessity - to save Padme, not just because he lusted power.
After 20 years of terror for the galaxy - and continued slavery for Anakin - he partially redeemed himself by carrying out another act of necessity, saving his son.

Now, we all know that the main reason Anakin turned to the Dark Side was to save Padme, but that wasn't the only reason. He was angry at the way the Council treated him, and undeniably he did lust after more power. But, due to Palpatine's clever manipulations, young Anakin saw the only way to save Padme was to turn to the ways of the sith. Even during the fight with Mace Windu, the crux of Anakins arguement is that he needs Palpatine to save Padme, regardless of whether or not he's a sith.

Even Dooku, who was one of the lost 20, dallied with the idea of turning back to the Jedi. Maybe because he forsaw the path Palpatine was taking re: recruiting Anakin to his side.

Once turned, Vaderkins is trapped in his decision and can't turn back. Padme is dead, his former fellow Jedi largely dead and frankly, he has nowhere else to go. His decision, made out of necessity, haunts him until the final minutes of his life, when he makes another choice of necessity and saves his son.

I say necessity because Vader doesn't HAVE to save Luke. Palpatine has decided that Luke will not turn, and is carrying out his promise of killing him. By saving Luke, Vader could be condemning himself to death, as Luke is to replace him. So, instead he takes the logical way out and kills Palpatine instead. But Luke is his son. He made Luke an offer at Bespin, much like the one made to him, only Luke rejected it whereas Vader accepted. Trapped, Vader knew that Luke would be the one to end the sith - effectively be The Chosen One - and therefore it was necessary to allow him to do this.

Vaders life was one of slavery and obligation, but despite this even he knew that there were necessary choices to make, and he made them.


ewanandhaydenfan5
I Have You Now!
date Posted: Aug 15, 2007 10:34 AM
Great blog!

You just made me think of something. Ani's main reason for going Sith was to save someone he loved (Padme), right? In ROTJ, on the 2nd Death Star, when Vader realizes that Luke has a sister and threatened to turn her, he was using basically the same manipulation against Luke, i.e., using Luke's love for someone to drive him over the edge. Obviously, Luke's and Ani's situations weren't identical, but the same idea was there: realize that a loved one is threatened, get angry, desperate, give in to your fear/anger, turn dark.

I wonder if GL did that on purpose, or if it's just a coincidence.
Qui-Tom Servo loves Padme
You Must Unlearn What You Have Learned
date Posted: Aug 15, 2007 2:43 PM
I think the parallels between Anakin and Luke's journeys were done on purpose. I wonder what Luke would have chosen had he not seen what his father's choices had done.

The irony is that Anakin made choices that returned him to a life of slavery. It is only at the end that he chooses freedom over slavery when he fulfills his destinty by destroying Palpatine. As I'm reading through Sacrifice, it strikes me just how stupid Jacen Solo is because he is choosing to ignore the painful lessons his grandfather learned.
jkthunder
Seven Pieces
date Posted: Aug 16, 2007 9:03 PM
Perhaps there are two examples of dark siders gone good: Kyle Katarn and Mara Jade. Neither were all that bad to begin with necessarily, but maybe that's a kind of commentary on humanity. "The good" is in all of us, but we are challenged by the dark sides in our lives.

It kind of makes you wonder if Palpatine was ever an innocent playful little child, or if he is perhaps some pure product of darkness.
janlomona
Smugglers Rants
date Posted: Aug 18, 2007 1:44 PM
Good point, Mara could certainly be seen that way, going from dark to light, and I love the observation about Palpatine. What were his 'Anakin on Tatooine' years like?
  Fish1941
date Posted: Aug 24, 2007 10:08 AM
Most fans choose to believe that Palpatine was born evil or that he was the epitome of Satan. I think that it is easier for them to believe this extreme contrast of good and evil than to accept the possible moral ambiguity in everyone.
  • Please log in to post comments