Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Words from L. Meridith
date posted: May 19, 2005 4:16 PM
Here it is: My ROTS Review (First Impression)
To you loyal readers: Expect a more detailed review later, once I have seen the film again. For now I will just give a summary of my thoughts from last night.

Overall, I enjoyed the film. Apart from of few minor quibbles (The annoying battle droid voice, the opening space battle seemed a little scattershot, Padme the Zombie girl brushing her hair) and one major quibble (recycled music while Anakin marched on the temple), I enjoyed the movie.

Unfortunately, the sound at the theater I went to was well below the theaters normal standards. That, and the uncomfortable seat, slightly distracted me. Also, some of my favorite parts and lines from the illustrated screenplay did not make it to the screen, which slightly dampered my experience.

Yoda was awesome. Nuff said.

As of right now, I give the movie a 8.5/10, placing it #4 on my list of all six movies.

1. ESB
2. ANH
2. AOTC
4. ROTS
5. ROTJ
6. TPM

After viewing it a second time, preferrably with better sound, it could very easily improve.