Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Musings from the Shadowlands
date posted: Sep 17, 2006 11:22 AM
interesting dilemma
I will start this by saying that there may be some spoilers from the Dark Nest series but Troy Denning, so be aware.

While reading this series, and interesting question came to mind. Just what role should Jedi have in government? One example is Raynar Thul, although admitidly, this is a strange and extreme example. His use of the Force banded together all of the Killik nests under one mind, a hive mind. Another example is Emperor Palpatine. He was exerting such a strong will that when he died, all the crews fighting the Alliance became nearly combat ineffective.

One also must consider the role of the Jedi in the galaxy. Jacen Solo has struggled with this. The role of a government is to serve the people. However, the role of a Jedi is to serve the Force. It is my belief that is why the Jedi were so easily destroyed in the PT. They became mired down by the daily squabbles of the galaxy and succumbed to their own bueracracy(sp). It is my belief that the Jedi should have no part of government and must remain seperate altogether. If the will of the Force says they must intervene, then they must becaome involved. Until then, involving themselves in the mindless muck that is daily galaxy politics only weakens them.

  Aush
Exploring the Expanding Universe of Star Wars
date Posted: Sep 17, 2006 12:05 PM
This is quite a dilemma. I always thought that Luke should keep his Jedi separate from the governments of the galaxy, but then how would the Jedi be able to exist? They'd have no money to sustain themselves. The only thing the Jedi can do is get involved with the government (like pilots, commandos, diplomats, senators, etc) which is what one individual in the New Jedi Order told Luke in Destiny's Way. It is a dilemma because no matter what the Jedi do, something isn't going to go right; even in the Legacy of the Force series, Luke and the Jedi still struggle to find their place in the galaxy (even though they've sworn themselves to the Galactic Alliance).
cowboy_11c
Musings from the Shadowlands
date Posted: Sep 18, 2006 6:39 PM
I had thought of this and that is the dillema. I wrote this before I read the end of the last book in the Dark Nest series. Luke expresses almost exactly what I wrote. My question was how much influence should Jedi have in daily politics.
  Aush
Exploring the Expanding Universe of Star Wars
date Posted: Sep 18, 2006 7:39 PM
I'd say little to none. They seem to always trap themselves and are unable to get out of it, so they should avoid it. But sometimes, things just can't be avoided so the Jedi step in, then they'll just be pulled into another direction and unable to get out. The Jedi should stay out of daily stuff, but if they even get involved with anything bigger, they'll be pulled in and that will destory them. Overall, I agree with you cowboy_11c :)
  • Please log in to post comments