Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Miss Padme's Naboo Love Nest
date posted: Dec 15, 2005 10:11 PM
Dark Lord: The Fair and Balanced Review
Dark Lord is up there with Labyrinth of Evil (also written by James Luceno) as the two best SW novels this year. It takes place weeks after ROTS as Darth Vader grows accustomed to his new persona and his new body, burying his old self deep within. Meanwhile, some Jedi survivors of Order 66 are on the run, trying to come to terms with what has happened and decide how to survive in this new dangerous galaxy. All of your favorite SW characters make cameos: Bail Organa, Mon Mothma, Artoo and Threepio, Tarkin, Chewbacca (actually he has a substantial role toward the end), and Obi-Wan, among others.

Teh Meh: The Jedi OCs in this story initially survive only because some of their clonetrooper buddies choose not to kill them. I had a hard time buying that and frankly at this point in the book, the clonetroopers seemed quite out-of-character. Fortunately, it's at the very beginning and they are "dealt with" quickly. The OCs aren't too bad, but for moving targets, they take up a little more time in the story than I would have liked. I would have preferred more time spent on Vader. A Jedi named Shryne runs into by sheer, unbelievable coincidence his smuggler mother. Come on, even a soul as forgiving as I am found that hard to buy. This is a tiny nitpick, but at one point Luceno is cataloguing all of Vader's injuries on Mustafar and it mentions that his eardrums melted. Eardrums do not melt. They can pop but not melt.

What Rocked: Pretty much everything else. The canon players are all remarkably in-character. I found Vader's struggle to adjust, his growing confidence in his new self, and the shift from being angry and bitter Anakin stuck in a suit to a committed Sith Lord determined to one day seize power from Sidious compelling to read. So much so, I was almost cheering him on when he went after Jedi. (Vader fangirls will find his fight scenes a turn-on.) The mental games between him and Palpatine also make for interesting reading. Almost as engrossing were Bail's scenes. As troubled as he is by the new Empire, Leia's safety comes first. He even lets Senator Fang Zar get killed because he just couldn't put Leia at risk. It explains why Bail doesn't dive headfirst into the Rebellion, which Mon Mothma is itchy to do.

The book also explains why the Death Star took so long to build, why the Wookiees were enslaved, and gives a simple explanation for why Obi-Wan brought Luke to Tatooine...at the time, Obi-Wan thought Anakin was dead. He finds out in this book his old buddy is still alive and has a freakout. He considers taking Luke away from the Larses and going somewhere else, but Qui-Gon's spirit advises him that Vader will never come to Tatooine...the place is too painful for him and it would risk reawakening Anakin. Sounds like a solid explanation to me.

Bottom Line: Whether you read EU all of the time or not, this book is for movie fans, addressing some of the post-ROTS/pre-ANH issues fans have wondered about. If you're a Vader fan, or an Anakin fan, I highly recommend it.

  Grand Admiral Veers0
date Posted: Dec 15, 2005 10:26 PM
Henceforth you shall be known as Darth... Vader
Thank you, my master
Rise


Do I need to say more? Hell no!
Darth Vader
Meditation Chamber
date Posted: Dec 15, 2005 10:56 PM
Quite good review you got there. I agree on almost every thing you said and I too would have wanted more in depth Vader (yes more, more and more!) than hearing stupid Olee.

A great read, and an awesome sequel to LOE and ROTS.
Darth Vader
Meditation Chamber
date Posted: Dec 15, 2005 11:06 PM
You seem to have quite interesting stuff here and on your other blog/s. Glad I found you! ;) I'll try to catch up on all this stuff because it really seems good. Cya around! ]:)
Sithhunter123
The melodic line of the saga
date Posted: Dec 16, 2005 1:45 AM
I do agree with what you say. I loved the book too but found the clones acting out order 66 a bit odd, the fact it only happened there is quite odd if u ask me. When I first read the book I was pretty dissapointed that we only meet Vader a quater of the way through the book
  Luke Fly_swatter
date Posted: Dec 16, 2005 1:46 AM
Great review. Is this book available in England? I've looked everywhere for it but apparently it's only available in the US. What's the deal, short of buying it online? (Which would defeat the object, as I'm wangling to get this as a "surprised" birthday pesent...)
  Luke Fly_swatter
date Posted: Dec 16, 2005 2:01 AM
Erm..."surprise" birthday present, not "surprised" birthday present. That would imply that the book would be surprised to be given to me as a present, which is highly unlikely. Erm...
  Darth Valor 7
date Posted: Dec 16, 2005 3:36 AM
good reveiw i agree 200%
  Aush
Exploring the Expanding Universe of Star Wars
date Posted: Dec 16, 2005 10:44 AM
I was worried about the commandos not obeying Order 66, but before it happens, James Luceno explains, through the characters, why these particular clones did disobey. The good thing is that these four commandos are the only clones who disobey; if all the other Jedi lived because of the clones, I wouldn't be too thrilled.

Also, what's better than the mind games of Palpatine and Vader along with decapitation of all who challenge Vader? Nothing can beat that.

- yub yub
MissPadme
Miss Padme's Naboo Love Nest
date Posted: Dec 16, 2005 8:44 PM
Thanks Darth Vader! I hope you enjoy all of my entries here.

Luke Fly_swatter, I know someone who got the book from Amazon.uk but I don't know about book shops.

Aush, I don't know it just didn't seem to me too in-character for these guys. They're one ladder rung above battle droids, bred to take commands.
  Luke Fly_swatter
date Posted: Dec 19, 2005 3:53 AM
Thanks Miss Padme. Looking forward to this one.
  • Please log in to post comments