Hello, you are not signed on. |
|
![[ Blogs.starwars.com ] [ Blogs.starwars.com ]](/static/skin/default/img/title_banners/site_banner.jpg) ![[ Write A Blog ]](/static/skin/default/img/nav/write_off.gif) ![[ Categories ]](/static/skin/default/img/nav/categories_off.gif) ![[ About Blogs ]](/static/skin/default/img/nav/about_off.gif) ![[ Troubleshooting ]](/static/skin/default/img/nav/troubleshooting_off.gif) 
|

 | Moose Poodoodate posted: Jan 18, 2006 11:47 AM | updated: Jan 18, 2006 2:52 PM |

 | The Right to Write |
 As we type out our blogs and emails and whatnots today, let's wrap our collective melons around this one...
So I heard this week that there are school districts that are considering dropping penmanship and cursive from their curriculum. The reason? The school day is packed now, and there simply isn't time. More importantly..like..who writes? Right?
I remember we used to have Typing Class. Typing was this elusive office skill that you had to struggle through for an entire year to achieve mediocre results. The offices of yesteryear used to have "Typists" - people specially trained to type things, because idiot fogey bosses weren't trained to do something so administrative in nature. Now we type lines around those old times. Kids typing 80 wpm with one hand. Or we're all thumbs a-blur, texting on our cell phones. I remember last year, during a Psychology class I was taking at a local college, that it actually pained me to write something longhand. It hurt. It gave me cramps to write 100 words. It occurred to me that I had not actually written anything in who knows when. I, the twit who nearly failed Typing Class, am now a Typist.
For me, and for most of the modern world, typing has overtaken the seemingly permanent fixture of writing with one's own hand. Is that a good thing?
"Writing" (and I mean "Writing" in the old sense - you know, using one's hand, or whatever appendage pleases you, to make symbols on paper) was king. Writing was a right that people fought wars over. In ancient times, learning to write, and to read, was a privilege often denied the lower classes. See, if peasants could read and write, they could communicate with each other secretly, and that meant conspiracies could bloom and revolutions start right there under the heels of your oppressive boots. And once this Right to Write was gained for the masses, they never let it go. It flourished, and Writing was the way of the world.
Each and every great speech from Abraham Lincoln was handwritten. All the plays penned by Shakespeare were..well...penned. Reams of paper came home from huddled soldiers in countless foxholes and trenches, scrawled hastily with whatever implement they could beg off their buddies. The whole of history is brought to us by hand, on walls of caves, on walls of stone, on parchment, or on paper, by candlelight, bonfire, or cities ablaze with changing times.
And so now Bubba and Eunice on the local school board want to just sort of..erase Writing. Kids use keyboards these days, so why do we need penmanship, they ask. Why waste time with cursive and print, with pencils and pens...
So interesting to me, this train of thought.
Because indeed,
Why do we need Math classes when we have calculators?
Why have Spelling and Grammar classes when we've got Spellcheck?
Why do we have Literature classes when we have Cliff Notes?
Why do we have Art when we have Photoshop?
Why do why have Athletics when we have video games?
And why do we have History classes when we can just Google it?
Go ahead, think of a class for any burgeoning young mind, and I bet there's a joystick, keyboard, reference guide or search engine that can replace it. Why do anything ourselves any more? Why not hand it over to this handy new Information Age that someone else, somewhere else has compiled for us?
As you replace the uses of the mind, so you replace the mind. You may think this a small concern, but to unlearn what humans struggled to teach for centuries and hand it over to machines that may or may not be there some day in the future is short-sighted and obscenely convenient. The more we do things with our own hands, the less someone can take those things from us.
"Idle hands are the Devil's playthings."
-- Unknown
"Either write things worth reading or do things worth the writing."
-- Benjamin Franklin
"To be a well-flavored man is the gift of fotune, but to write or read comes by nature."
-- William Shakespeare
"Reading maketh a full man; conference a ready man; and writing an exact man."
-- Francis Bacon, Sr.
"The liberty of speaking and writing guards our other liberties."
-- Thomas Jefferson
"Abraham Lincoln, his hand and pen, he will be good but God knows When."
-- Abraham Lincoln, written in his schoolbook as a young boy
"Don't be too proud of this technological terror you've created..."
--Darth Vader - More machine than man.
DM out
PS-
Please handwrite your responses.
Can't? See what I mean?...
|

 |
http://blogs.starwars.com/moosepoodo/69 |

| |
Darth Rex0 So be it....
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 11:52 AM
Each and every great speech from Abraham Lincoln was handwritten.
There is something very personal about seeing some of those documents. It gives you a sense of seeing something Abe saw while he wrote it. Very cool. It reminded me that Mozart's music sheets never had one mistake on them and were written in pen. Amazing when you think about it. Seeing someone's penmanship gives you a limited look at who they were. You can see the scratch paper Lincoln wrote the Gettysburg address on and see his scratches as he thought about what he wrote, or the perfectness of the brilliant mind of Mozart (although it was music not words).
|

 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 11:55 AM
It gives you a sense of seeing something Abe saw while he wrote it. Very cool. It reminded me that Mozart's music sheets never had one mistake on them and were written in pen. Amazing when you think about it. Seeing someone's penmanship gives you a limited look at who they were.
So astute. Whereas the eyes may be the window to the soul, handwriting may be the window on the mind, even a mind from long ago.
|

| |
Darth Rex0 So be it....
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 11:56 AM
That being said, my handwriting is horrible. I remember having to stay in from recess and working on the letter I in cursive. Couldn't do it. So looking at my manuscripts and seeing all the scratches would only give you a look at how horrible my handwriting is and not a look at who I was. It is an artform almost, some are have great handwriting and some don't. Some are great mathmaticians and some aren't. I'm not sure it should be taken away in schools. My two cents which probably wasn't worth that.
|
 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 12:05 PM
That being said, my handwriting is horrible.
As is mine - I used to think it was the old myth about being a genius, now I know its from atrophy.
|
| |
Darth Rex0 So be it....
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 12:06 PM
some are have great handwriting and some don't
Just like some have good grammar and some don't. DM any chance of getting spell check or grammar check on these things? Yeah, I know I can cut and paste from word, but who has time for that? I might as well handwrite a comment and send it in....
|
| |
The Infinite Force Infinite Galaxy Of Fun - (Retired Archive)
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 12:11 PM
All kidding aside, this is very disturbing. Not enough time for writing? Why go to school at all then? You have to learn reading, riting, and rithmetic.
But this is all part of a larger picture these days that I see even in older kids: poor communication skills, especially in the ability to speak and orate ideas. You can't expect to get a job when you can't even talk in the interview effecively.
|
| |
Darth_Starius
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 12:15 PM
I might as well handwrite a comment and send it in....
lol , i probably have the worst handwritting. damn you misses jone for making me stay in class and try to perfect that skill you made me miss recess and pop. oh well thats an other subject
|
 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 12:15 PM
DM any chance of getting spell check or grammar check on these things?
They have these ancient devices called "Dikshun Harry's"
|
| |
Aadi_Rila Jedi Master to my God-child
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 12:21 PM
What's really sad is that my 16yr old cousin doesn't even know how to write and essay, on the computer no less. That is, she doesn't know how to form an essay, with the introduction, the basis and the conclusion. She's only 7yrs younger than I, but I would be able to write an essay at the moment given the assignment! I think the problem is we are losing our focus on what's important and the schools/teachers are more worried about being 'friends' with the students.
|
| |
bluejedi32 The Force Is All Around Us
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 12:28 PM
I agree with you all the way Dark Moose!! You need to send this blog to those retards on that school board. Maybe it will make them think about what they are doing, to take writhing away from school.
|

 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 12:34 PM
I think the problem is we are losing our focus on what's important and the schools/teachers are more worried about being 'friends' with the students.
Yep, I think what's gone a little wrong with schooling today is they seem more focussed on the studen't future career rather than the studen't present mind. They assume that most of the population is going to be going into positions somehow connected with the Information Age, and so keyboarding and technology are starting to edge out the basics of learning.
Gimme a ruler and a thick book and I'll give you a well-behaved, smart kid. :0) Or at least one smart enough to be afraid of the ruler and can tell what the little numbers are for.
|

 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 12:45 PM
I think also what's wrong with schooling today is they choose the direction of the student before they even have a chance to do it themselves. They mandate choices too early, and they train students in areas that preclude their eventual vocations.
Whatever happened to finding your own way? Why not give students the ability to think for themselves by arming them with the right kinds of basics, instead of loading them up with a slanted agenda?
|

 |
NerfHerdersAnonymous Life, the Star Wars Universe and Everything
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 1:02 PM
As a person who loves to write letters for snail mail, it shocked me to learn that some would like to replace handwriting altogether. Though by the looks of things they've already eliminated any trace of spelling handbooks for our young.
Not that I think of this often in gloom and doom terms but...if something cataclysmic happens and we are left without use of our electronic marvels, what then? We've already removed, or in the midst of removing, many "outmoded" forms of education out of our schools because we thought the need for a computer literate youth was far more important.
Should be interesting to see what happens to us. I can't imagine our brains getting any larger (as predicted) if things are done for us.
LM
|

| |
Master_Kenobi17 Takin Over For Talon
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 1:03 PM
Well, I live in SoCal and we have a problem with students getting behind, mainly the ones who can't read, write, or speak english very well. More and more programs and lessons that could benefit the multitude of students are thrown out because of the minority who can't keep up. I have always despised this, as the lefties on the school board feel that if all the children can't be on the same page, so to speak, then something is wrong. It's the school board who prevents students from blossoming and finding their own way. The school board and the politicians... The students must pass by any means necessary, the board thinks, so that they can get their money from the state. It all comes back to the $$$
|

| |
Master_Kenobi17 Takin Over For Talon
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 1:06 PM
Yes, I agree with Nerfherdersanonymous, if something terrible happens, like the- ever-predicted-by-us-geeks rise-of-the-machines, where will our younger crowd be?
|
 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 1:12 PM
It's very much in line with our propensity to consolidate learning. I've pointed out before the trend even, ironically, applies to Information Technology.
See, the people that originally knew how computers worked are people that know low-level stuff like Assembly and Electronics and Binary. The next step was software that combined several elements and commands into simpler commands. And then another language was made to combine even further. And then GUI was added so that most commands aren't even needed any more - there's no more COPY or EDIT or LIST, there's just click and drag.
|

 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 1:13 PM
And now we're beyond the 4GL languages into very powerful apps and tools like Oracle and Cognos - but it's not programming any more, it's application usage. Everyone is a glorified "superuser" now. Even developers, to a certain extent. And what of those low-level folks that know circuits and boards and binary? They aren't compensated $150 an hour like the person that can build data warehousing cubes in Oracle. They barely break $40k in some cases. Think those people will be around long?
So what happens someday when everyone knows how to develop high-level stuff, but no one can tell you how a processor works? And all the processors are fried? And machines made the processors? What then?
|


| |
Mando Crusader
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 1:46 PM
So, today we had our first ICT lesson in school. Now ICT skills are on our National Curriculum, so naturally, as our school was "found lacking in IT development" (or something) in the last OFSTED report we now have to learn it. Now, as we are not timetabled to have IT the teachers had to find some way to fit it in. This means shifting a lesson out of the way to make room. Guess which lesson of ours get replaced. Thats right SE- social education (which is not on the curriculum, I don't think). If we're not going to learn how to be a good citizen and instead learn how to align paragraphs on a computer and other such nonsense, what are we going to do in a situation when we don't have a trusty Pentium processor to help us out?
|

 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 1:48 PM
The students must pass by any means necessary, the board thinks, so that they can get their money from the state. It all comes back to the $$$
Money is easier come by in privatization. You know, product sponsorship is slowly leaking into colleges. Am I going to send my granddaughter to school with a big Nike or Pepsi patch on her uniform some day?
Dunno, but you're right, either way, it all comes down to money, and where they think the money will be.
|

 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 1:50 PM
Guess which lesson of ours get replaced. Thats right SE- social education (which is not on the curriculum, I don't think). If we're not going to learn how to be a good citizen and instead learn how to align paragraphs on a computer and other such nonsense, what are we going to do in a situation when we don't have a trusty Pentium processor to help us out?
I can't tell you how many developers I know that can code up some C# like nobody's bidness, but can't speak to, oh, you know...human beings. They'd rather look at their screen or their own shoes than talk to a live person.
Problem there is, most of our customers are human beings...
|

| |
DarthVicomte Vicomte's Blog Extravaganza (Now Defunct)
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 1:51 PM
Whatever happened to finding your own way? Why not give students the ability to think for themselves by arming them with the right kinds of basics, instead of loading them up with a slanted agenda?
They still have the ability, they just have to work harder to use it. I find fighting a slanted agenda makes the finding much more rewarding, and fun, I might add.
And machines made the processors? What then?
You've read "The Hacker and the Ants"? That's how it starts, robotic ants make more robotic ants, ants rule the world.
|
 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 2:10 PM
They still have the ability, they just have to work harder to use it.
But if they don't know to, if they've never needed to, then working harder to is tad irrelevent to them.
|
 |
NerfHerdersAnonymous Life, the Star Wars Universe and Everything
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 2:21 PM
And what of those low-level folks that know circuits and boards and binary? Think those people will be around long?
My g-5 grandfather, David Tannenberg, built organs (US) during the 18th c. A small group of highly skilled organ builders (for love not money) found a disassembled organ, built by DT, in an attic and used their existing knowledge of modern organs, their love of ancient organs and research of "hand - written" documents to rebuild and restore it.
I bet most here had no clue people still built organs let alone restored ancient ones. It'll be the same with computers, someone will cling to the "old ways" there too.
|

| |
DarthVicomte Vicomte's Blog Extravaganza (Now Defunct)
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 2:22 PM
But if they don't know to, if they've never needed to, then working harder to is tad irrelevent to them.
Only if they don't want to. Needing isn't important, the interest is motivation enough, or should be. Knowing is a bit different, every semi-sentient being knows to think for itself, it's just much easier to have someone else think for you. It's instinctive.
Of course, the easy path is always the one to the Darkside, funny how that works out, idn't?
|
| |
DarthVicomte Vicomte's Blog Extravaganza (Now Defunct)
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 2:25 PM
It'll be the same with computers, someone will cling to the "old ways" there too.
But something always happens to the clingers, whether it's the organ-maker down the street or Darth Vader, it never seems to work out right. At least in the long run.
|
 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 2:28 PM
It'll be the same with computers, someone will cling to the "old ways" there too.
I don't doubt it, but I can see a harrowing process some day of having to scour the world for a handful of people who know an archaic hobby that is actually the basis for our modern civilization. kinda scary.
|
 |
NerfHerdersAnonymous Life, the Star Wars Universe and Everything
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 2:42 PM
harrowing process some day of having to scour the world
Yes, very difficult to find. Especially with all our resources gone.
...hey a book. Write it, become famous and we'll talk of how it all started here.
But something always happens to the clingers, whether it's the organ-maker down the street or Darth Vader, it never seems to work out right. At least in the long run.
I think you've been watching too many movies. hehe
|
 |
jkthunder Seven Pieces
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 4:41 PM
handwriting comment then transcribing it to comment box...
well, at least we dont have to paint on cave walls to record how the hunting season went anymore... unless we want to.
|
| |
Son of a Bith The Cantina Corner
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 7:34 PM
Good point. When the power goes out, you can still use paper and a pen, and they don't catch viruses and keep asking you if you want to enlarge your genitals.
And you can stab people with a pen, not a computer or a typewriter.
|
 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 8:12 PM
BRODY: Henry, the pen- !
HENRY: What?
BRODY: But don't you see?! The pen is
mightier than the sword!
-- Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
:0)
|
 |
Michelle1968 M68- Star Wars Kid at Heart
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 8:22 PM
Very interesting, I enjoyed reading this one...
Here's a thought. Relating it to the world of Star Wars, have any of you ever seen, heard or read of anyone handwriting anything throughout the SW Saga?
A long time ago in a galaxy far far away, what were they doing?
|
 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 8:53 PM
Good point, and glad you enjoyed the entry...
In a universe where technology is ancient and pervasive, it would make sense that there is no such thing as a pen. I can't think of a single scene with someone writing. I was thinking about this when I wrote this blog entry....
And think, then, if someone else takes over the holonet, and the manufacture of computers and datapads...and there is no written word. How easy would it be to cut people off from one another?
|

| |
Darth_Meerkat Rants of a Mere 'Kat
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 9:04 PM
Great blog, DM. In the schools in my town, the teachers are putting up a great fight to keep handwriting in the cirriculum. (I heard a few even banned using computers on assignment entirely.)
Michelle, I think the Chiss kept their entire library handwritten in Basic.
Whatever happened to finding your own way? Why not give students the ability to think for themselves by arming them with the right kinds of basics, instead of loading them up with a slanted agenda? Actually, the board in my town let tried to make it so students got the basics, and were left to decide if they wanted to continue in other fields. The lessons are slated in favor of English, Humanities, and Math. Seems like the district like writing by hand.
|

 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 9:21 PM
In the schools in my town, the teachers are putting up a great fight to keep handwriting in the cirriculum.
That's encouraging to see teachers fight for some of the core values of education.
|
| |
Darth_Meerkat Rants of a Mere 'Kat
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 9:40 PM
Encouraging for writing in general, yes. Encouraging when a teacher goes crazy and makes students re-write a final draft of an essay. After the brainstorming, rough draft, editing, final draft. I mean, I'm all for keeping writing alive, but that seems a bit extreme.
(Mostly because I was the student re-writing the essay!  )
D Mkat over and out
|
 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 18, 2006 10:27 PM
Encouraging when a teacher goes crazy and makes students re-write a final draft of an essay.
Wow - proof of my theory that every school has a Mrs. Perrata, my old AP English teacher.
Just like every culture has a burrito by a different name, every school has a Mrs. Perrata.
She's like the Agent Smith of English Teachers...
|
| |
cestus183
|
date Posted: Jan 19, 2006 4:58 AM
*eyebrows raised*
i don't know about schools in your area but mine focuses on writing and concepts, in addition to critical and creative thinking. *shrugs*
we don't have that problem so badly here.
|
 |
The Dark Moose Moose Poodoo
|
date Posted: Jan 19, 2006 6:10 AM
Well, I think this also depends on how active the parents are in an area, and to what end. Folks in North Dallas can be a bit...well...superficial. NYC Wannabes I call them, but they've got no clue what a New Yorker is. The dreaded "helicopter" parent syndrome runs rampant in many school districts because everyone wants their kids to be "competitive" and "viable". So brilliant ideas like replacing writing with something else is born. You know, it occurs to me everyone knows how to keyboard in time. You can't avoid it. But writing is a skill that can easily be neglected. It is, as a previous poster pointed out, an artform, and a personal expression.
|
| |
Mando Crusader
|
date Posted: Jan 19, 2006 8:44 AM
Perhaps a day will come when the humble graffito artist will become the sole preserver of a dying art...
|
| |
Darth_Meerkat Rants of a Mere 'Kat
|
date Posted: Jan 19, 2006 4:34 PM
Wow - proof of my theory that every school has a Mrs. Perrata, my old AP English teacher. You only had one? Jeez, I have 5. They call it a teacher alliance. Luckily, my teacher is the new one, so shes kind of lenient with us, but the others make the Kaminoan KE-7 enforcers sound desirable. I mean the ones with electro prodders.
D Mkat over and out
|
| |
Diviner525 In the Flesh
|
date Posted: Jan 19, 2006 8:03 PM
DM, I think this does have alot to do with a specific area. Maybe even the size of the community as well. We live in a smaller community (~14,000) and the schools here and the surrounding communities seem to really have a good balance between 'newer' skills and more 'traditional' skills. The local schools are teaching computer skills, for sure, but not at the expense of manual skills such as handwriting, math, art, music, physical education, etc.
(cont)
|
| |
Diviner525 In the Flesh
|
date Posted: Jan 19, 2006 8:05 PM
We don't have any kids yet, but as an engineer I'm invited to speak at local junior high and high schools for 'Career Days' and such - which is alot of fun for me. And I get feedback from the students on what they've been studying. As well as what my niece and nephew tell me about their classes (they also live in a small community).
D525.
|

| |
JediPandora27
|
date Posted: Jan 20, 2006 8:16 AM
Moose, I compelety agree about keeping handwriting in schools. Personally, mine is a mishmash of cursive and print, but I enjoy writing by hand. Every story I have ever written was by hand. I recently bought a laptop to work on when I travel, for writing, notes, to keep track of things, to stay in touch... but simply because I feel guilty for killing a lot of trees when I fill up notebooks with ideas or whatever. I don't even keep a physical checkbook anymore, but an electronic one in Excel. However, I think students have to learn to write by hand in school, because it isn't a skill that comes naturally.
|
- Please log in to post comments

|
|
 |