Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Mark My Position
by: RW
date posted: Nov 07, 2005 7:52 PM  | 
updated: Nov 07, 2005 7:52 PM
Yoda's Claws vs. the Chancellor's Podium
Yes, you have heard it. You've cringed at it. You know you have. That screech -- that most dreadful and painful screech -- before which all men and women, young and old, flee.

See, there are a few things in this universe which, each day, we must all do our best to avoid. One is getting kicked in the groin. Another, and the most relevant to this entry, is the unholy sound of fingernails on a chalkboard. It is a sound that tries men's souls.

Heck, even Aristotle, the great fourth century philosopher, noted the "aversive" qualities of the scraping sound. And researchers from Northwestern University have also studied the matter, which they have dubbed impressively the "psychoacoustics of a chilling sound."

Now, fingernails on a chalkboard is bad. According to the Northwestern University scientists' research, the rubbing of two pieces of styrofoam together is bad too. But equally pervasive is a certain scene in Episode III -- the one where we learn the true power of Yoda's claws.

When Yoda, tired and defeated, falls from the Chancellor's podium, he finds it necessary to scrape his long, sharp claws against the thing. These mere five or six seconds of viewer pain form what I am now going to boldly call the worst moment in the saga.

If there is any good in this world, Lucas will one day go back and make a "special edition" version of the prequel trilogy, presumably for release in a special box set of futuristic "LK3P" discs or something, and he'll remove the scraping scene.

A man can hope, anyway.


  AnAkAiNsOlO
Star Wars: The Final Frontier
date Posted: Nov 07, 2005 7:59 PM
Yes, man can only hope. :D

Solo out
  shatterpoint282
''This Party's Over ''
date Posted: Nov 07, 2005 8:05 PM
I want special editions of the prequels like Peter Jackson did with LOTr extrascenes added in and I want a revision of Palpatines office so that Agen Kolar , Kit Fisto and Saesee Tiin don't look like wimps.
  padawannacracker?
"We're Smarter than This." "Apparently not."
date Posted: Nov 07, 2005 8:28 PM
God, I wince evey time at that little bit.
  Darth Kevinmhk
date Posted: Nov 07, 2005 8:32 PM
Yoda was NOT defeated! at least not in the lightning.
The explosion throw both of them away!

and Yoda was NOT defeated in saber duel too!
you could see many of Sidious' sword move hit nothing but air,
failing to intercept Yoda in mid air, and Yoda broke 2 of Sidious'
saber locks

but ya, he might be tired.

by the way look at Palpatine's stupid move to climb back on the pod...
why didnt he just overleap? he could even jump to the pod beside
or a pod which is just 1 level lower..
  Darth Kevinmhk
date Posted: Nov 07, 2005 8:36 PM
by the way we could see that Palpatine was actually
very, very arrogant:

He made no attempt to defense when Yoda got on his feet.
i.e. he believed his lightning already defeat Yoda completely

he was full of surprise when he got on his feet after the Force Push,
wondering why Yoda could counter attacked so quickly

He had a look of surprise for a second when Yoda blocked
his exit, i.e. he didnt believe Yoda could still leap after the lightning

when Yoda was countering his podium, Sidious didnt do anything,
he just laugh and laugh, until his own podium was going to hit him,
he again was surprised for that

when Yoda counter back his lightning, his face really, really full of surprise!!
  Lieutenant Wiggum Jansen
DETENTION BLOG AA23
date Posted: Nov 08, 2005 3:51 PM
I didn't expect Northwestern Scholars when I clicked on this...boy I was surprised!! :) Hopefully Lucasfilm will release a Screeching and Non-Screeching version. In the Non-version, the sound will be replaced with gently tinkling water.
  Darth Kevinmhk
date Posted: Nov 08, 2005 6:51 PM
actually i could accept the sound, no matter in the movie or in real life
  RW
Mark My Position
date Posted: Nov 08, 2005 6:56 PM
actually i could accept the sound, no matter in the movie or in real life

You're a braver man than I, then. :P
  • Please log in to post comments