Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

The Alternatives to Fighting
date posted: Apr 15, 2006 1:04 AM
You were the Chosen One!
I was going to save this particular topic for a later date, but when I realized my blog was inexplicably chosen as "Blog of the Day", I decided to haul out a (hopefully) worthy entry.

As my friends and I begin work on our loving parody/remake of Revenge of the Sith (to join the legions of its fellows), seeing the film many, many times is in order to get the right feel for the flow and pace. In doing so, it raises questions and reveals answers the casual viewing might not. During a recent viewing, I recalled one of the gripes of many of my fellow fans besides the Jedi's apparent obliviousness to Order 66 (see an earlier blog of mine for this discussion) was Anakin's seemingly lightswitch-like turn to the dark side.

I've seen it many times in the parodies... Anakin arrives in the Chancellor's office, stands around for a minute, lops off Mace Windu's hand and suddenly becomes Darth Vader. For many, it seemed like the "Hero With No Fear" just spastically decided "Sure, I'll be evil and kill everybody" and was off to the races.

But his fall only seems sudden if the only movie you are watching is Episode III. It is important to remember that Anakin's descent into darkness is chronicled in all three prequel films. Revenge of the Sith is only the very climax.

"Once you start down the Dark Path, forever will it dominate your destiny; consume you, it will. As it did Obi-Wan's apprentice." These were Yoda's words of wisdom to Luke in The Empire Strikes Back, and after having seen Episode III, it is clear what he meant. Once Anakin got past a certain point on his journey to the dark side, there was no turning back. Or so it seemed.

That point was clearly the slaughter of the Tusken Raider camp in Attack of the Clones. His strong attachment to his mother meant that her death at the hands of the sandpeople drove him into a fit of rage, as it would for any of us, really. The difference is, with his control of the Force, it is far easier for Anakin to exact his revenge than it would be for the average person. It's not that there is some weird property of the Force that causes Dark Side users to slide down a slippery slope of evil, it's just plain human nature. Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Once Anakin realized how easy it was to kill the Tuskens using the Dark Side of the Force, he would be more inclined to use it in the future. Humans (or perhaps I should say "beings") are more inclined to take the path of least resistence, and when the easiest thing to do is evil, chances are it'll be done anyway.

Which brings me back to my main point. Anakin Skywalker's fall to the Dark Side doesn't begin or end in Episode III, and he could have turned out all right if any one of several factors hadn't been applied. First off, he started training far too late, and had already formed an attachment with his mother. Secondly, he formed another attachment to Padme, and an overwhelming one at that. Third, he witnessed his mother's painful death and took his anger out on the entire Tusken village, opening himself up to the Dark Side. Finally, his overwhelming attachment to Padme proved to be a powerful weakness when he began having dreams about his beloved's death. (Personally, I think Palpatine was ForceFaxing these images into Skywalker's head, especially since they don't EXACTLY match the actual event, despite being reasonably detailed.) It was just the straw that broke the camel's back, as they say, pushing poor Skywalker over the brink. He was willing to do anything, ANYTHING to prevent Padme's death.

And Palpatine knew it.

  iam obikenobi
date Posted: Apr 15, 2006 4:47 AM
wow that was good (i dont judje goder) i think ure right it was too soon


''die jedi darts"
YodasPadawan4
Star Wars Appreciation Society
date Posted: Apr 15, 2006 8:26 AM
Excellent blog, and right on target. At first blush, the turn does seem sudden, but if you watch all 3 movies together, its obvious this is a guy who was teetering on the brink almost all his life. Another thing to add is his frustration at the Jedi Council. All his life he has been told he is The Chosen One....Palpatine whispering in his ear that he is the best of the best, the greatest Jedi ever...and yet the Council won't let him be a Master. Anakin's arrogance makes him believe that he is being overlooked, that nobody trusts him or believes in him despite his power. Palpatine sees an easy mark in Anakin, and it doesn't take much to push him over that edge.
Caparran
date Posted: Apr 15, 2006 12:24 PM
At the point Anakin cut off Mace's hands, he pretty much had nothing to lose going for what Palpatine poisoned him with and plunging into the Dark Side. Remember, by this point Anakin had already lost Qui-Gon and Shmi as support figures, and now he would have to do just about anything to prevent something terrible from happening to Padme and losing everything. It was simply too unfortunate that no one in the Order after Qui-Gon died ever gave Anakin any positive encouragement or compassionate guidance to keep him from giving in to his passions.B-)
Caparran
date Posted: Apr 15, 2006 12:36 PM
Oh, yeah.

After being freed and helping out liberarting Naboo, Anakin should have not been permitted into the Order. That way he would have become the best Podracer in the Galaxy, earn enough credits to get that something more "real" stuff Watto likes to free Shmi and buy her a house on Naboo. His racing would have gotten Padme's attention for sure (Chicks dig Racers) and they would have married and had the twins anyway lol. But how the prophecy would have been fulfilled then, who knows.]:)
  padmeskywalker77
Padme's Legacy
date Posted: Apr 15, 2006 1:34 PM
Great blog...and as YodasPadawan4 said right on target. Although I agree that Anakin's fall is apparent when you watch all 3 PT movies, if you watch closely enough in ROTS, you can see the slow downfall during this time. To me, this fall begins with Anakin's dream and then just spirals down from there...he tells Padme "I feel lost...Obi-Wan and the council don't trust me..." Here, you can feel his conflict between good and bad, and his feelings of insecurity. His attachment to his mother before his joining the Jedi Order, then his attachment to Padme and thier secret marriage helped to contribute to these feelings and his downfall.
  Oboe-Wan
Oboe-Wan's Hive of Scum & Villainy
date Posted: Apr 15, 2006 5:34 PM
Odd, I was thinking about this exact thing this afternoon!! When I first saw ROTS, I thought the same thing: wow, that was quick. But then I had to remind myself that the entire PT is about his consumption by the dark side.

Initially, I thought Anakin would fall the way Luke almost did - a sort of subtle, insidious, "I was taunted" kind of way. Anakin really gave in to his dark side and couldn't undo his mistakes. I love the comparison between father & son and how each confronts their demons.

Congrats on being blog of the day!!
jkthunder
Seven Pieces
date Posted: Apr 15, 2006 7:26 PM
But his fall only seems sudden if the only movie you are watching is Episode III

See, I never thought it was quick at all, except for the fact that the galaxy was rapidly crumbling all around them and Anakin was acting out of desperation in a way. Change happens real quick in times of chaos.

And I agree certainly that the whole PT is a prelude to ROTS then the OT, but I found ROTS to work as a stand alone film too. There's all sorts of subtlties that led up to Anakin's need to make a decision one way or another, within ROTS itself. Everything exploded at once; Anakin, the Republic, the Order.

  jediorder3113
date Posted: Apr 17, 2006 5:13 PM
i think that u are right that Anakin Skywalker's fall to the Dark Side was a result of many factors, but i differ with you in the point that (It was just the straw that broke the camel's back) i think that the bond that he had with padme was the main reason he fell in the dark side it is not the only reason.
  jediorder3113
date Posted: Apr 17, 2006 5:14 PM
i liked that you used the word attachment which is the key word for his fall to the dark side.from my point of view i think that his attachment to padme had about 65% effect on his fall and to his mother had about 25% effect and the power thing had about 10% effect. i think we can see that in the return of the jedi when he killed Palpatine it was to save his son not because that he can kill Palpatine, Personally i think he could have killed him any time he wanted to anakin is more powerful than palpatine, but it was attachment which he found with his son.
and i want to add that your blogs are really good.did you or any one you know thought about R2-D2.i think you should give it a thought
JawaJoey
Return of the Jawa
date Posted: Apr 17, 2006 5:29 PM
Great analysis. I agree, that Anakin was on the edge for a long time, so his "sudden" switch really wasn't sudden at all.

I also like the point you made about the Drk Side and the Force. For normal people, being evil is simply a matter of being mean, but when someone like a Jedi has a lot of (potentially very deadly) power,a nd they slip into darkness, the effects are much stronger.

Evil is just bad without the Force, but when combined with the Force, it's much mroe powerful and consuming, which is very dangerous, and is why the Sith are so much worse than any other bad guys.
jedimastermartin8
Star Wars History
date Posted: Oct 14, 2006 1:32 AM
He told him about it.
  • Please log in to post comments