Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Oboe-Wan's Hive of Scum & Villainy
date posted: Jan 30, 2006 10:40 AM
Star Wars Music Appreciation 101
Ironically, this musician has not yet written a blog on the music of Star Wars. There seem to be plenty of blogs out there about how great the music is or how inspiring, but I want this one to be different. I don't pretend to know everything about John Williams or the composition of his music for the films. I have not actually sat down and done a thorough analysis of the music, such as I did as a music major in college. I remember listening to Mendelssohn's Italian Symphony continuously over several days (and by continuous, I mean I listened to absolutely nothing else) as I pieced together a paper for Music Theory V: Form & Analysis. Quite frankly, now as a professional musician, mom and functioning human in our society, I don't have that much time. Also, I'm 99.44% positive that there isn't a soul that will want to read a blog with in-depth analysis of chord progressions, form on macro- & micro- levels, instrumentation, etc.

So what I'm hoping to achieve here is to give you some of the tools you need to enjoy the music of Star Wars on a slightly deeper level than perhaps you're used to.

1. John Williams draws he melodies for his movie scores from other composers. Most composers/songwriters will tell you that they find inspiration from the music they listen to. It is not uncommon to outwardly quote melodies (in classical music: Antonin Dvorak's New World Symphony, mvt.3 is a quote of a Beethoven Symphony; Watch the Coldplay Live DVD and you'll hear them talk about how they tried to write a "Kate Smith Song"; the examples are endless) and it is very common to compose a little "nod" to your favorites. Apparently, John Williams must be a fan of Igor Stravinsky. Looking especially at "Star Wars: A New Hope" soundtrack you will hear several similar examples of this. Most prominently is "The Little People Work" and "The Desert and the Robot Auction": clearly based on Igor Stravinsky's Ballet "The Rite of Spring."

Hearing the opening string pizzicato accompaniment and interjections from the winds, anyone familiar with The Rite of Spring recognizes this at once. Enter the English Horn (tenor oboe) solo above the string pizz. and you are certainly reminded of the "Dance of the Adolescents" from Rite of Spring. There is a small bassoon solo, very high in the bassoon range, a direct nod to the bassoon solo which begins the entire Stravinsky Ballet. Lastly, my absolute favorite part of John William's orchestration technique is his ability to write rockin' Tuba solos! There is a wonderful tuba solo 2:17 mark on "Little People Work", which to my ear sounds as if it is a kissing cousin to the tuba solo in Stravinsky's "Petrushka" Ballet.

If you are not familiar with the music of Stravinsky and love these tracks from the SW soundtrack that I have mentioned, I highly recommend you pick up some Stravinsky, beginning with "Rite of Spring", "Petrushka", and "Firebird". Great CD's are those with Leonard Bernstein directing the New York Philharmonic Orchestra. Stravinsky was a composer of the first half of the 20th century. When the "Rite of Spring" premiered, most audiences were familiar with Tchaikovsky Ballets (Nutcracker, Swan Lake, Sleeping Beauty, etc.) and were appalled at the music and "sexual" choreography of "The Rite of Spring." When the ballet premiered in NYC a riot actually broke out in the audience and the performance had to be stopped.

2. John Williams was a student of Henry Mancini. Known best for his music to "Breakfast at Tiffany's" (Moon River springs to mind) and composer of the ever-popular "Baby Elephant Walk" Mancini is one of those great composers who manages to mainstream his movie music by giving us memorable melodies and formats (in this case: pop songs) which general audiences can appreciate. John Williams excels at this skill as well. Just listen to the track "Cantina Band" with it's swing and techno-jazz sounds - need I say more? The jazz band on this song is great! I hear a reed ensemble of saxophones and clarinets, faintly in the background there is a bit of trombone (flutter tongue during the rhythm section break around :37). Our rhythm section consists of steel drums standing in for the usual piano which gives this rhythm section it's more "galactic" sound, bass and of course drum kit. At 1:30 we get the percussion section "solo" where you can hear these instruments better. Bass is doctored up - to my ear I hear a fretless bass with some serious effects to give it that unworldly sound. Our reeds also get a few "effects" for the main theme though throughout we do hear a pure clarinet in the breaks. This leads me into my next section....

3. John Williams' affinity for certain instruments and avoidance of others. Clarinet is certainly very low on JW's list of instruments to feature in the orchestra, rarely soloing in anything except the "jazzy" tracks such as Cantina Band. For those who may not know, an orchestra consists of these instruments: violins, violas, cellos, bass (string section), flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon (woodwinds), trumpet, trombone, french horn, tuba (brass) and any combination of percussion & drums (including piano, harp, timpani). Most of the principal players, or "first chair" if some of you remember that from your school band days!, are featured as soloists. JW loves to feature the flute and oboe (Leia's Theme), trumpet & brass (Main Theme), tuba ("Little People at Work"), English Horn, this as you remember is a larger oboe, is one of his favorite's to feature. As an oboist but in particular an English horn player this makes me happy knowing my instrument is so prominenty featured by one of my favorite composers. :D

4. John Williams is a master at quoting his own music. Oh sure, we all know that at the end of Anakin's Theme in The Phantom Menace JW closes out with a few notes from our favorite Imperial March. But what about some other quotes? They are everywhere! A few snippets here, something else there. A little quick blip from the flutes to remind us of the Asteroid Field from Empire Strikes Back. But my favorite is found in the Phantom Menace. The track is named: "Watto's Deal and Kids at Play." There are innumerable quotes in this track. The scene is when Anakin is working on his pod racer, Shmi discloses to Qui-Gon that Anakin has no father, etc. etc.. Ever pay attention to the music? Listen carefully you'll hear a bit of Anakin's Theme morph into Luke's at 2:30. Keep listening just a bit further to 3:06 - the music swells as Anakin yells, "It's working! It's working!!" Recognize the melody? That is a small quote from the 1997 SE of Return of the Jedi - the new song JW wrote for the Ewok Celebration. This is a beautifully subtle quote from the OT. It's just a few notes but enough to satisfy both my SW and music needs.

5. Common misconception perpetuated by JW himself: Anakin's Theme Is a 12-Tone Row. WRONG! Twelve notes in a row do not constitute a 12-tone row. In a pure 12-tone row, all 12 pitches of the octave (c, c#, d, d#, e,f,f#,g,g#,a,a#,b) are used before any can be repeated. Sure he uses all twelve in this melody, but several are repeated before we hear all 12 of them. As a historical note, Arnold Schoenberg, master of this form, is rumored to have used this form of composition to pass codes during WWII. Could explain why 12-tone music is not for the "casual" listener.

6. John Williams didn't use a chorus in Star Wars until Return of the Jedi. Um.... perhaps someone can clear this up better for me, but I am certain that there is chorus is Empire Strikes Back on the track "City in the Clouds" . At the 5:25 mark there is a faint undertone of voice a la 1920's style orchestral/choral music. This would make sense as George Lucas was trying very hard to make the OT feel like a Flash Gordon serial - why not have the music reflect the same style? If I ever have the honor of John Williams himself reading my humble blog and he feels the need to clarify, this musician would be forever grateful.

And here ends my dissertation on some of my favorite points of John Williams' soundtrack for the Star Wars Saga. I hope you learned something (either about the music or about why I'm a nutjob!). Thanks for sticking with me to the end!

jkthunder
Seven Pieces
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 11:09 AM
youre like all into music and stuff

:D
  DarthVicomte
Vicomte's Blog Extravaganza (Now Defunct)
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 11:14 AM
The steel drums always get me on Cantina Band, we need more SD solos in music, methinks.

The bass definitely sounds like a fretless, I hear Jaco had some free time for that one........;)

I always liked Leia's Theme a lot, good flute can be hard to do, most of it sounds overdone, but not for that song.
jkthunder
Seven Pieces
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 11:16 AM
4. John Williams is a master at quoting his own music

yup - i read that as more movies were made, and the movies got longer, JW (and GL) pulled elements from previous movie scores and integrated them especially with the prequels. its nice like this, and sometimes those "quotes" are barely recognizable but they do enhance the whole tie-in aspect throughout the SW films.

I am certain that there is chorus is Empire Strikes Back on the track "City in the Clouds"

did you check the liner notes for choral credits? if there isnt any, could it be possible that this is an instrument(s) made to sound choral? ive heard of composers doing this, borrowing from asian music.
  laserswords
The Pen Is Mightier Than The...Laser Sword?
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 12:10 PM
This was a pretty interesting read, right now I'm in a music appreciation class, It's my first one, so I'm just learning about all this stuff. Thnks for wrting so much on it!
  Oboe-Wan
Oboe-Wan's Hive of Scum & Villainy
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 1:01 PM
I don't see a choral credit in the liner BUT it is possible that the musicians themselves are singing. SPeaking from experience we're asked to do that a lot in fact.
  SithMonkey11
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 1:09 PM
I do hope you are not knocking John Williams with No.1, I really hope you don't accuse him of plagarism. If you mean inspiration who doesn't?
amidalooine
The Emotional Galaxy
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 3:18 PM
The music quotes are what "make" the music for me, and I DO listen for them, hear them, and love them. Often when I get a shock of emotion as I listen to a particularly moving piece, it's a direct reaction to a quote of the other episodes' themes. The more I listem to mt CD's the more convinced I am that JW is a genius.
Darth Vader
Meditation Chamber
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 4:44 PM
Great info! Having no music education whatsoever, this will be really helpful next time I watch the movies or listen to the soundtracks. I had no idea about the 90% of the stuff you mentioned. I don't think there is a chorus in ESB, but what do I know anyway... ;)

I do hope you are not knocking John Williams with No.1, I really hope you don't accuse him of plagarism. If you mean inspiration who doesn't?

Go read it again. Then apologize.
mirax7
The Saga Begins
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 6:43 PM
i knew there was a reason i was not a music major in college. :D

oh and if you ever do a thorough analysis of " of chord progressions, form on macro- & micro- levels, instrumentation, etc." i will NOT be available for comment! :p :x
jkthunder
Seven Pieces
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 6:55 PM
hmmm - i listened to this clip and i think i can hear what you are talking about - http://www.teletracks.com/audio/empire93_4_6.ra (this is a real player file) - its from the following page - http://www.filmtracks.com/titles/empire.html

anyway, it real sounds like voice, but the way the brass fades in soon after makes me think it could just be from that.
jkthunder
Seven Pieces
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 6:57 PM
woops - looks like my first link there is bad - just go to the second link and scroll down the page a little - find the sound clips on the left navigation bar for 1993 fox anthology>city in the clouds ;)
  Son of a Bith
The Cantina Corner
date Posted: Jan 30, 2006 7:20 PM
Jkthunder-the link you provided was interesting. But one thing made my blood boil- It says in the article that Al-Qaeda has used the "Imperial March" theme in its propaganda videos.X-(

If those #######s really paid attention to the movies, maybe they wouldn't be terrorists.
  Oboe-Wan
Oboe-Wan's Hive of Scum & Villainy
date Posted: Jan 31, 2006 5:35 AM

Can I tell you how many times I've listened to those few seconds of City in the Clouds to figure out what that is?? For the life of me I can't figure it out. Initially, flutes & oboes are trilling very low which at first was what I thought it was, but the "voice" increases to the point where it can be recognized as something separate from woodwinds. The only thing I can think is perhaps it's viola's with mutes on harmonics OR some percussion (like a bowed gong). Who knows! Perhaps it's electronically generated - like feedback.
  Oboe-Wan
Oboe-Wan's Hive of Scum & Villainy
date Posted: Jan 31, 2006 5:43 AM
do hope you are not knocking John Williams with No.1, I really hope you don't accuse him of plagarism.
"plagarism" is not a word associated w/music & composition as it is next to impossible to plagarize (as you would with written words) so this would only refer to song lyrics. Guitar riffs can be copyrighted. In classical music you can't really copyright melodies or harmonies, so.... you do the math.

It just sounds to me like you need to reread that paragraph of the blog to hear what I was actually saying.

  Oboe-Wan
Oboe-Wan's Hive of Scum & Villainy
date Posted: Jan 31, 2006 5:43 AM
oh and if you ever do a thorough analysis of " of chord progressions, form on macro- & micro- levels, instrumentation, etc." i will NOT be available for comment!
Mirax, run away, run far away! I will go with you!! Not to worry, someone else can do it! I have a....what do you call it....a LIFE!!
  cbern
Omega Squad's 5th member
date Posted: Jun 24, 2006 6:27 PM
great blog

i can see some of williams's stuff in tchaikoscky's music (or however you spell it)

i love to play the themes and other songs at home (on piano and alto saxophone)

it is nice to know that there is some one else here who likes music
  James Earl James
date Posted: Nov 22, 2006 3:35 AM
Hi there and sorry I'm soooo late on posting here (I just found this on a link from Google).

As a fellow musician and composer I've analysed this music quite closely. Perhaps I can help clarify some points here.

I've no idea whether John Williams is a fan of Stravinsky or not (although I assume he is). The point is that the pieces from The Rite of Spring were used on the original temp score created by Lucas. Originally he wished to use existing classical music rather than new music so he had created a temp score from Stravinsky, Holst, Dvorak, Walton, etc.
  James Earl James
date Posted: Nov 22, 2006 3:37 AM
The Tatooine piece is the closest that Williams sticks to the temp score (a little too close if I may say) but the other scores are evident throughout the film. Quotes from Holst's Mars are apparent during the opening sequence and when the X-Wings approach the Death Star. William Walton is another whose music was used in the temp score and can be heard in the Battle of Yavin and Throne Room music.
  James Earl James
date Posted: Nov 22, 2006 3:37 AM
John WIlliams is a master of quoting and re-using his own music. A really nice one to look out for is the end music from The Phantom Menace. A children's choir sings the celebration music on Naboo.. but listen closely and you'll discover that it's the Emperor's Theme at a faster tempo harmonised with major chords.

Great article anyway!

James
  Oboe-Wan
Oboe-Wan's Hive of Scum & Villainy
date Posted: Nov 22, 2006 8:19 AM
JEJ THANK YOU for clarifying a bit there. I hadn't picked up on the end of TPM, but I will have a listen.

I'm excited to find out that he did actually use Rite of Spring in the temp score because for me JW's music just screams RoS!

Thanks for wandering over here to read this, doesn't matter how "late" as long as you make it!! Keep stopping by! Always nice to connect with other musicians especially here at sw.com!
  James Earl James
date Posted: Nov 22, 2006 3:09 PM
You're totally welcome Oboe-Wan.

Couple of other points: I believe John Williams stated that Anakin's theme was based on a 12-tone row.

I can't find out whether there was a real choir for 'City in the Clouds'. It may have been synthesized.

regards

James
  • Please log in to post comments