Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Fragments from the Mind's Eye
date posted: Nov 10, 2005 10:13 AM  |  updated: Nov 10, 2005 11:41 AM
Internet Kills UFOs
I have a topsy-turvy melodramatic relationship with the Internet. Oh, some days I adore it: the convenience of online shopping, the coolness of seeing aerial photography from around the world, the ability to instantly look up the name of that bad movie that starred what's-his-name and who's-that-guy.

Then, there's the dark side of it all - the realization that many of the people that have suddenly been given voices aren't really worth listening to, posts from 30-year old men declaring jihads against Mattel because their re-issue of the Man-E-Faces figure came with a mis-colored toe, or other examples that make me believe the slogan of one of my favorite websites (which I won't link to here): "The Internet Makes You Stupid."

But, like every otherwise powerless online pundit, I'm happiest when the Internet proves a point for me. And an article at Tech Central Station summed up an argument I've been having against the credulous for a while now. To sum up, it's this: flying saucers have never been real.

When compiling Lucasfilm Fan Club Magazine #8 for online publication (Hyperspace members can read it here), I was taken by a quote from Steven Spielberg who, in 1989, was still a firm believer in alien visitation of the planet Earth. There's a scene in Close Encounters of the Third Kind where a believer, challenged by the skeptical argument that no photographic evidence exists of UFO visitation, counters with the fact that there are no photos of plane crashes and other such rare but verifiable phenomena, yet no one doubts that plane crashes exists.

Later, during the press push for War of Worlds, Spielberg recanted his position of a decade earlier, using a variation of that very same argument. Now that everyone is carrying a camera with instant online publishing and forwarding capabilities, it seems a little suspicious that aliens have suddenly stopped visiting the planet. As for plane crashes, since the '90s, I've managed to see at least a dozen of them, on video or as still images. Heck, I'm sure there's enough for a FOX "World's Most Amazing Plane Crashes" TV special. Yet, there's not enough UFO photos to provide a single shred of evidence for this phenomenon.

Likewise, despite the proliferation of mini-DV camcorders, cell-phone cameras, and unrestricted blogs, there has yet to be no solid proof of ghosts, chupacabras, vampires, Loch Ness Monsters, hollow earths, or faerie-folk. Oh, there are websites that can dress up these fantastical creations with an air of authenticity, but in the end it's just some guy's website in some dusty corner of the net. Where's the unmistakable proof that should be available at our fingertips? Surely if the blogosphere and the media combined can ferret out specious claims of yellow cake uranium, we should be able to find absolute evidence of telekinetic ability or people who can really, honestly talk to the dead!

One of my heroes, James Randi, is still offering a million dollar reward to anyone who can prove paranormal powers under double-blind experimental conditions. That money isn't going anywhere.

So, while I'm proselytizing, let me share three of my most firmest held beliefs:

- Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof.
- The natural, visible and scientifically-examined universe around us is more wonderous, magical, and awe-inspiring than the delusions of the credulous.
- Skepticism doesn't exist to say, "no this is not true," but rather, "okay, but isnt it far more likely that..."

RIP UFOs. From 1947 to 2005, you had a good ride. Look out ghosts, leprechauns and Bigfoot, you're next!

ph

lovelucas
date Posted: Nov 10, 2005 10:58 AM
but......the day the earth stood still will now only be appreciated for its hidden warning. the creature that walks among us is joseph mc carthy with no chance of alien arrival?

sounds like jocasta nu - if we don't see it, it's not there and never has been. i'll go with obi wan.
The Dark Moose
Moose Poodoo
date Posted: Nov 10, 2005 11:25 AM
posts from 30-year old men declaring jihads against Mattel because their re-issue of the Man-E-Faces figure came with a mis-colored toe..

Bah! :0) that made giggle. See? The Internet, though slow and dangerous behind the wheel, can still serve a purpose.

I hold to this idea - the truth is in the averages, not in the extremes. For one, Internet Negativism is not to be taken seriously. Look at the forums at LucasArts.com. After a much anticipated release of Battlefront II, I've never seen so many miniscule yet passionate complaints ranging from background music to floor textures. And yet the game is outselling BF1.
The Dark Moose
Moose Poodoo
date Posted: Nov 10, 2005 11:26 AM
I liken Internet Negativism to that one audience member at a classical Bach concert that stands up and yells "Freebird!". Definitely more noticeable, but its still just one dude with a lighter.
Pabawan
Fragments from the Mind's Eye
date Posted: Nov 10, 2005 11:44 AM
Heh. Great analogy.

I'm a moderate in just about everything, but the Internet is still mostly extremes. But, maybe that's an extreme point of view. :)

the truth is in the averages, not in the extremes.

Yep. That tends to be the case. Humanity is a lens that distorts in both directions. Given the two extremes that a) our planet is visited daily by UFOs and we're just crops to be harvested by the great and all powerful Xenuvian Crystal Empire and z) no aliens exist anywhere and none ever have, I think the truth is around m) Intelligent alien life is likely out there somewhere, but it's too far away to impinge on our daily grind.

ph
Detective J. K.
date Posted: Nov 10, 2005 12:32 PM
I'm with you on this ...

... except for the chupacabra! It's real! There was an X-Files episode!

I don't think I want to live in a world that has no chupacabras or dinosaurs that live in lakes. Maybe that's just me.
  Darth Rex0
So be it....
date Posted: Nov 10, 2005 4:14 PM
Ever since the creation of writing, information has always been twisted or manipulated so people can try to convince someone else of "something". Whether it be UFO's or what god to follow, information when made available easily, like it is on the internent, will always be subjected to extremes. When the internet was first born, all we could think about was how cool it would be to have all that awesome information at our fingertips. What do we do with it? Post on movie websites, look up lyrics, and maybe check the weather. Why? Because you can't believe half the stuff you read on the internet and there are so many extreme websites.
  Darth Rex0
So be it....
date Posted: Nov 10, 2005 4:15 PM
Great topic and by the way, the Chupacabra is real, I found this cool website about it.....
  King of the Jawas
Tales of the King
date Posted: Nov 10, 2005 9:04 PM
I still see various UFO reports on the news.
Karen Traviss
"Cannon to right of them, cannon to left of them...noble Three Million!"
date Posted: Nov 11, 2005 6:49 AM
You can get away with testing a lot of weird military aircraft if you just say, "Ooh, look! UFOs!"

And why do people persist in believing that the Bemuda Triangle is paranormal when geologists demonstrated what happens to ships and aircraft there years ago?





eddie
Obsessive Fanboy Eddie and his Timeline Chronicles
date Posted: Nov 12, 2005 12:28 PM
It's because people want to believe (just as I want to believe that the UFO phenomena is real (and that there is this big worldwide cover-up)... Hey, it's my next big thing next to SW... :)
  King of the Jawas
Tales of the King
date Posted: Nov 13, 2005 8:47 PM
Agree there!
  jSarek
jSarek's Infonet
date Posted: Nov 16, 2005 10:36 PM
I don't know why people don't believe in UFOs. I mean, I see them all the time, flying around or maybe just hovering there.

Granted, I eventually identify almost all of those flying objects, but for that brief time . . .
  Diviner525
In the Flesh
date Posted: Nov 17, 2005 8:41 PM
Speaking of online shopping, my copy of Star Wars Chronicles: The Prequels that I ordered a while back from Barnes & Noble arrived this week.

Wow. It is absolutely fantastic. You and Steve Sansweet (and everyone involved in putting this book together) are really to be commended. This is an incredibly detailed book - and a great collector's item. Thanks from this very happy SW fan!

D525.
  Ice Zero
A Cynic's Guide to the Galaxy
date Posted: Nov 18, 2005 1:06 AM
I don't know why people don't believe in UFOs

By the literal definition, UFO's, Unidentified Flying Objects, indeed exist. There are all manner of strange lights floating in the sky and atmospheric anomolies out there. Heck, I even saw me a "UFO" once myself. The question is, are these mysterious sightings of extraterrestrial origin? My take: not likely. I believe that it is a near mathematical impossibility that another form of life does not exist somewhere out there in the perhaps unending reaches of space, however, the chances that such life has ever payed us a visit is next to zero.
  Ice Zero
A Cynic's Guide to the Galaxy
date Posted: Nov 18, 2005 1:06 AM
Furthermore, I think the SETI project and its Arecibo monstrosity are delusion-inspired boondoggles. One has a better chance of hearing voices on the other side of the world by placing an ear to the ground.
  Ice Zero
A Cynic's Guide to the Galaxy
date Posted: Nov 18, 2005 1:07 AM
Furthermore, I think the SETI project and its Arecibo monstrosity are delusion-inspired boondoggles. One has a better chance of hearing voices on the other side of the world by placing an ear to the ground.
Rainbow Droideka
Aren't you a little short for an egg?
date Posted: Nov 18, 2005 4:32 AM
And why do people persist in believing that the Bemuda Triangle is paranormal when geologists demonstrated what happens to ships and aircraft there years ago?

Crop circles are in a similar situation. Patterns that were deemed "impossible" for people to create have been demonstrated and documented to be just that - creations of people. And yet, the Travel Channel still airs shows about people who say, "Okay, but not *this one* - this one makes me feel funny when I stand in it."

The Bermuda Triangle "mystery," on the other hand, doesn't even exist outside of manipulation of statistics. An interesting article: http://www.skepdic.com/bermuda.html
Dan Wallace
Continuity, Criticisms, and Captain Panaka
date Posted: Nov 20, 2005 9:29 PM
While I support the sentiment behind the article, I can't help but notice it was lacking in stats to back up its claim that the "internet killed UFOs." I bet anyone here a Mint On Card Man-E-Faces action figure that the percentage of people who believe in UFOs is virtually unchanged from 10 years ago, and will be virtually unchanged 10 years in the future. There's a primal appeal in latching on to unknowable stuff like aliens or Nessie or vast government conspiracies. Heck, lots of people think the government faked the Apollo moon landings.
Rainbow Droideka
Aren't you a little short for an egg?
date Posted: Nov 29, 2005 8:47 PM
I bet anyone here a Mint On Card Man-E-Faces action figure that the percentage of people who believe in UFOs is virtually unchanged from 10 years ago, and will be virtually unchanged 10 years in the future.

Well, when you put it that way, that's not a bet I'll be taking. :)
  • Please log in to post comments