Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Reflections of a Grey Jedi
date posted: Jun 03, 2007 4:06 AM
Review: Hard Merchandise (BHW)
Title Hard Merchandise (BHW)
Author: K.W. Jeter
Pages: 338
Time: 4 ABY

Introduction
By the time I started to read this novel I was pretty much fed up with the bounty hunter wars story. I had hoped the last story would be short, be it appeared to be even larger than the second part. Why? I cannot imagine, the story is far to thin to be spread out across two novels and now it is even being spread into a third one. Needless to say, my initial thoughts about the novel were 'a bit' negative. You can read below, whether they have changed.

Novel quality
While this novel still uses the past/present story structure it now focuses mainly on the present. Somehow the focus has gone from the bounty hunters guild to the situation on Kuat. The first part of the novel is used to tie up the story around Xizor and the Emperor. The story ends rather unsatisfactory as nothing really happens to any of the major characters in the story. Sure the story is ok, but nothing that happens has any real implications for the future. This seems a bit of a shame as you have just read through about 400-500 pages of story and then end up with an ending that doesn't really mean anything to the galaxy.

The second part of the novel focuses on the present situation of Boba Fett who is in the process of delivering Neelah to Kuat. Neelah will play an important role in the story as Kuat Drive Yards is at the breaking points and starts to receive some extra attention from the Rebel Alliance. The Alliance seems to be very interested in Kuat Drive Yards, but Kuat of Kuat does not want to share his company. This is finally some relevant information. We see how the Rebels behave themselves just around the final defeat of the Empire. We also get served some more plotting, this time within Kuat Drive Yards. This is however also totally irrelevant to anything outside of the story and therefore not very interesting at all. The ending of the story is ok, we get closure for all of the main characters and Mr. Jeter closes things in a satisfying manner.

All in all you'll have to read through more than a thousand (!) pages to read a mildly interesting story with no real implications to anything outside of the story. I'll restate my opinion: "This story should have been written in one novel of around 450 pages!" By spreading it out over three novels and 1000+ pages the story is basically ruined. Don't get me wrong, there are things to like about the story, but it is all just too much work to read, to make it worth your while. My advice: Only read this if you want to read every single novel out there. If you don't, just leave it alone, nothing you have to know happens in these novels.
Rating: 65/100

Personal tilt
It's really a shame that the story has been spread out across so many pages. If the story would have been more compact, it wouldn't really have mattered that nothing extremely interesting happened. You would just have enjoyed the great interaction between Xizor, Vader and Sidious and you would have gotten some nice insight into Boba Fett's character. Now it's all just too much. It gets boring and you'll read about a whole bunch of totally uninteresting characters. Let's just say that I am really happy that I finally finished it and that I can now go on to the X-Wing series.
Rating: 45/100

Overall rating: 57.0/100

- - - -
See my Book review summary for other reviews and a my personal top ten.

  Clone Emperor
date Posted: Jun 03, 2007 7:36 AM
I admit that a story called "The Bounty Hunter Wars" should have less talking and more explosions.....But Boba Fett Piloting A Star Destroyer all by his Lonesome is a pretty sweet climax.
  masterkenobi93
confessions of a teenage star wars fan
date Posted: Jun 03, 2007 2:35 PM
I actually disagree, I thought is was a really great series.

MK93
  Count Meulstee
Reflections of a Grey Jedi
date Posted: Jun 05, 2007 12:14 AM
It's good to see that some people did like the series, funny to how different opinions can be.

For me it was like talking a lot but saying a little.
  Eirtaé
Rebel Heart
date Posted: Jun 08, 2007 1:00 PM
I'm sure you're going to love the X-Wing series! I absolutely love it, and the ones I love the most are the Aaron Allston ones, great humour and great action!
jedivan2
Jedivan's Viewpoint
date Posted: Jun 18, 2007 8:55 PM
My advice: Only read this if you want to read every single novel out there. If you don't, just leave it alone, nothing you have to know happens in these novels.

I'm also a little annoyed that the editors at Bantam missed the fact that Kuat of Kuat destroys the Kuat Drive Yards, but that in several books that take place later (but were published before The Bounty Hunter Wars series) Kuat Drive Yards is still building spaceships. Oops!!!! (The New Essential Chronology corrects this by saying that only part of the drives were destroyed.) Believe it or not, however, there are worse Star Wars novels than these. The Lando Calrissian Adventures by L. Neil Smith, for instance.

jedivan2
Jedivan's Viewpoint
date Posted: Jun 18, 2007 8:58 PM
My opinion on these books is about somewhat between yours and MK93's however. I'll get around to reviewing these books in my blog at some point.
  Count Meulstee
Reflections of a Grey Jedi
date Posted: Jun 19, 2007 11:34 AM
@ jedivan2

"The Lando Calrissian Adventures " ... , they really are weak, aren't they. My least favorite novels so far. Oh well, there's enough good reading out there to make me keep on going.
  • Please log in to post comments