Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

Rive's Uncharted Settlements
by: Rive Caedo
date posted: Nov 11, 2006 9:18 PM  | 
updated: Nov 11, 2006 9:43 PM
Wounds
Things are still busy, busy, busy over in the Caedoverse, but I'm making time for this entry because I don't want to drop off the map.... again :)
________________________________

"It is only natural. He cut off your arm, and you wanted revenge. It wasn't the first time, Anakin. Remember what you told me about your mother and the Sand People."
- Grand Chancellor Palpatine

Right there we have an example of a direct reminder of a plot line. We're one step away from Palpatine literally turning to the audience and saying "It's been 3 years since the last movie came out, do you remember what's going on?". I'm not a huge fan of that kind of plot reminder. It doesn't flow and it tends to drag you out of the moment that's actually happening right then.

In contrast, Anakin's gloved hand reminds us of the ending duel of Episode II and in the Original Trilogy Luke's hand is featured twice - the more important being when he looks at it and then at Vader's severed hand and draws the connection between them. But more relevant to my topic is when he draws a glove over it as he's heading to Dagobah. That moment reminds us not only of the fact that his hand was shot on Jabba's Sail barge, but also that his hand was cut off by Vader. Thus in 1.5 seconds - and without requiring Yoda to come up and say "Remember when you got your hand cut off? Do ya? Do ya?!" - we remember what we need to.

Anakin's scarred eye serves a different purpose than a reminder of events that have happened. It serves to show the passage of time and the war. We very deliberately don't know what happened (unless you read the expanded universe :p ). It heralds to adventures we didn't see in the same way that C-3PO's mismatched silver leg, the Millennium Falcon's junk-yard look, and any number of other "lived in" features of the Original Trilogy do.

The Emperor's wrinkled face and Vader's suit and the final reveal of his scarred head in Return of the Jedi have taken on entirely different meanings and storylines that they force us to recall over the decades - rather unique in the world of entertainment.

_______________________________________________________
Spoilers for Battlestar Galactica Season 3 (up until "Exodus II") follow!!!
_______________________________________________________

Battlestar has - in my opinion - taken this idea to the extreme. For those of you that don't watch Battlestar (start!) - our heroes got stuck on a planet under occupation of the evil Cylons (fancy word for "robots and cyborgy things"), that situation continued for... 5 episodes I believe. During the occupation we see dozens of character building moments and dramatic scenes... but then we get off the planet. How on earth are we going to keep this giant story arc fresh in peoples' minds?!

Hm... How 'bout we put a character's eye out?

Now every single time we see that character with the patch over his eye... We remember the occupation storyline without needing a character to pull us out of the story and say "I was on that planet 8 months ago! Remember that? Do ya?!".

_______________
Spoilers End Here
_______________

Hitting up 2 last thoughts really quick. Harry Potter has a very prominently featured wound (Harry's scar), but often does go out of its way to explain everything about it because the series is designed to appeal to peoples of all ages that may not quite be able to remember what's going on even with a little reminder. Serenity featured a brief scene with Captain Reynold's shirt off where we could see the scar from where he was hit with a knife in the second episode of the Firefly. In that case it was more of a nod to the fans than anything - although it also serves the purpose of showing "this guy has been around".

Star Trek - as far as I can think currently - is remarkably entirely void of this storytelling tool. The reasoning for that being that it is an almost entirely episodic plot based series, rather than character based. We don't need to remember that Captain Kirk got shot in Episode 23 because it doesn't matter for Episode 24, 25, 26, and so on.

So in my opinion (whose else would it be?), wounds, scars, and other permanent changes to a character's appearance are perhaps the strongest storytelling tool available exclusively to television and film. It allows for an entire storyline to be summed up in a single scar, missing limb, or patch eye.... Not a word needs to be said.

Is there any stronger tool out there?
_______________________________________________________
Rive "Pitifully Unscarred" Caedo
-Blog Index-
-Star Wars TV Show Guide-

  gahmah80
Gahmah's Lair of Trauma (Blog Closed Due to Inability to Renew Hyperspace Account)
date Posted: Nov 11, 2006 10:34 PM
Hey, sometimes we need them for the noobs. Or the forgetful ones (like Gahmah......sometimes). 'Nuff said. :D
  independentjac
"How long can any man fight the darkness, before he finds it in himselft?"
date Posted: Nov 11, 2006 11:27 PM
that was cool. thanks rive. I am glad you didn't diassapear. again.
jkelly
There Is No Conflict
date Posted: Nov 11, 2006 11:34 PM
Palps' line is a blatant overture, and it's done on purpose. Kind of like saying, "So, Anakin, do you want to become evil?"

Best symbolism ever? The 1960s version of A Man for All Seasons where Rich keeps getting nicer clothes as he sells Thomas Moore down the river..
  Jedi Arwen Skywalker
date Posted: Nov 12, 2006 9:21 AM
So, Anakin, do you want to become evil? Well, do ya?

Good points about a oft-used storytelling device.

Glad to see you around, wouldn't want people to think you were gone forever again. :)
The Stooge
Star Wars Joke-A-Day (gone fishin')
date Posted: Nov 12, 2006 9:40 AM
One day I'll have seen BG... and on that day, I'll go back and read all these blogs of yours. Ah, to dream.
jkthunder
Seven Pieces
date Posted: Nov 12, 2006 1:59 PM
First, I had a feeling this might be a BSG entry, then I started reading and thought "Oh my! It's actually about Star Wars... the films!!"... then I read some more. :D

:^O After all the drama surrounding this part of the story arc, I ended up letting out a big chuckle when Tigh vented at gaeta "Do you know where my eye is?" :^O

It was just so... pirate. He should've followed up with a good "ARRrrr!"

I have to say though, one of the great successes in the character driven story arcs of BSG, is that the characters are all changed in some way by the big experiences they've had. New Caprica was definitely extreme, and I think the emotional changes will keep the story moving just as much as.... Tigh's eye. *Giggle* :p
jkthunder
Seven Pieces
date Posted: Nov 12, 2006 2:08 PM
Don't forget Adama's scar from the attempted assassination either. Not quite as visible, but they've gone back to it and shown it after the fact.

Do Starbuck's tatoos count?

And that part about Palps... definitely a little "pointer scene" there. Those are never a good thing to use too much, but it was very minimal and subtle. The Star Wars saga is so epic and complex, as are the others you've noted, that verbal visual cues are certainly neccessary to tie it all together.
hansgirl3
Invoking the Squee
date Posted: Nov 13, 2006 11:36 AM
Is there any stronger tool out there?

Music? ;)

KIDDING!!

No, you're right... wounds do work wonders for reminding everyone of what has happened or let people know what MAY have happened. B-)
  Rive Caedo
Rive's Uncharted Settlements
date Posted: Nov 13, 2006 5:18 PM
Palps' line is a blatant overture, and it's done on purpose. Kind of like saying, "So, Anakin, do you want to become evil?"

Sure, which is why I just dislike the line, rather than hating it :)

One day I'll have seen BG... and on that day, I'll go back and read all these blogs of yours. Ah, to dream.

By then I'll be writing about "Buck Rogers in the 25th Century!" or "Space: 1999.1" or "Star Trek: The Final Generation: We Swear" or "Gilligan's Space Station". :p

I started reading and thought "Oh my! It's actually about Star Wars... the films!!"... then I read some more.

There are Star Wars films now? I thought it was just a catchy name for a blogging site.
  Rive Caedo
Rive's Uncharted Settlements
date Posted: Nov 13, 2006 5:23 PM
Don't forget Adama's scar from the attempted assassination either. Not quite as visible, but they've gone back to it and shown it after the fact.

Ooo, good one. Reminding us not only of the assassination but also of all the things that went wrong in the 3-5 episodes he was out of commission.

Do Starbuck's tatoos count?

I think that would fall under the same category as Threepio's silver leg. We don't know exactly when and why she decided to get them, but it adds a feeling that she's a real person that had a real life before the Cylons decided to blow up humanity :)

Or did we see her get the tattoos and I'm just being forgetful? ?:|
jkelly
There Is No Conflict
date Posted: Nov 13, 2006 6:17 PM
I meant that Palps did it on purpose, not GL making some of "hit you over the head" symbolism. Are we talking past each other or are you over my head?
  Rive Caedo
Rive's Uncharted Settlements
date Posted: Nov 13, 2006 6:26 PM
I meant that Palps did it on purpose, not GL making some of "hit you over the head" symbolism. Are we talking past each other or are you over my head?

I meant that I think it had dual purpose. It completely made sense from the Palpy "I'm turnin' ya to the Dark Side! Especially since I just had you kill my current apprentice oh... 30 seconds ago?". But the Tusken roar we hear in the background and the wording of the line itself is completely for the audience's benefit.
jkelly
There Is No Conflict
date Posted: Nov 13, 2006 6:55 PM
But the Tusken roar we hear in the background and the wording of the line itself is completely for the audience's benefit.

I agree it's a tool to educate the MTV generation on what's going on, but I like to think it's a taunt from Palps as well. As the former, I've resigned myself to acknowledging the need. As the latter, I like it. (I used "former" and "latter" as code because the MTVers won't get it)
Jedi Master Mina
Jedi blogging, go back to your drinks!
date Posted: Nov 13, 2006 6:56 PM
It allows for an entire storyline to be summed up in a single scar, missing limb, or patch eye.... Not a word needs to be said.

I agree to a point. Depends on the scene and movie. I think what George was trying to drive home with that line was the fact that Palpy was playing with Ani's head, making sure Anakin's fall is complete. That line makes the audience feel more anxiety and emotions towards Anakin's fall...IMHO.
jkthunder
Seven Pieces
date Posted: Nov 13, 2006 8:16 PM
Now I'm trying to remember about Starbuck's tattoo too. I'm pretty sure we never saw her get it, but there have been some small references to it... did we first see it when she was on that stealth mission back to Caprica to get the arrow of Apollo? They certainly flash it as a visual cue now and then.

Did you see Measure of Salvation? Pretty grim. It looks like the show is settling down a bit into the season. It still dealt with some crazy issues, but not quite as epic IMO.

LOL - Another BSG "wound" - Apollo's weight gain? :p
  Rive Caedo
Rive's Uncharted Settlements
date Posted: Nov 14, 2006 1:53 PM
Apparently she has three real tattoos and one fake one for the show? (seen here on her left arm).

I'm so confused : |

Did you see Measure of Salvation? Pretty grim.

I've felt an urge to cover up my ear since then :p
My main problem with that episode is that they still have the virus! It didn't just "disappear" when the Cylons died. They could extract it and use it. I have a feeling they won't deal with that issue though - because then the show would be over :)
jkthunder
Seven Pieces
date Posted: Nov 16, 2006 3:31 PM
Eggggxactly. I had some issues with the beleivability of Measure of Salv. Of course I suspend my disbeleif for the show anyway, but for this one it was harder. Of course they couldn't just kill off the cylons. Athena seemed to get off scott-free from the virus, which leads to other possiblities in the usual BSG style. But yeah, they still could use the virus. I think I'm just used to all the other shows this season so far being so huge, and this one just didn't quite *measure* up :p

I dunno - The one big tattoo on Katie's left bicep looks pretty real. I think they must "make it up" a lttle for the show, because it looks similar.
  • Please log in to post comments