Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date posted: Feb 07, 2008 1:42 PM  |  updated: Feb 08, 2008 1:24 PM
Review X-Wing Series books 1-4
I finished the first four books of the X-Wing series. The series switches authors in book five with Aaron Allston replacing Michael Stackpole. I am about two thirds of the way through the fifth book, and since the book has a different feel with Allston I thought this would be a good point to write a little review. I was inspired to read this series after several bloggers pointed out fond memories. The only bloggers I can remember off the top of my head are Slow and Smuggler Jedi, so I'll give them all the credit for getting me into these books!

The first book follows the reformed Rogue Squadron lead by Wedge Antilles against Ysanne Isard and the Empire. The book takes place after the death of the Emperor, the remaining Imperial leaders have broken away and many proclaim themselves warlords. Ysanne Isard replaced the Emperor and controls the greatest concentration of Imperial forces. The first book focuses primarily on Corran Horn and the new Rogues. Horn remains the central character throughout the first four books, but Stackpole spends a fair amount of time with other characters. One of the series strengths are the detailed accounts of space combat between the empire and the rogues. Stackpole follows the X-Wings through numerous loops and snaprolls as they close in and take out enemy TIE's. Its both a strength and a weakness in my opinion. On the one hand its great to have all the detail, on the other it can get confusing.

Now if Horn put his X-Wing up on the starboard S-foil and looped to port, then kicked in the repulsors to slow down and make a tighter turn as the squint (TIE Interceptor) turned to starboard, are they running head on or is Corran behind him??!!

It can be the literary version of shaky cam, fortunately anyone who has read Ender's Game can probably relate to this situation. (side note that is an awesome book!) The good thing is that you won't miss out on much if you do not follow each and every turn, and not every battle challenges one's spacial imagination. If you choose to read the series straight through, it can become tedious at times, a break in between books is not a bad idea so you can keep the repetition of fight sequences from becoming boring.

I would like to get into more of what I liked about the series but the action plays such a big part in the series I think I would be spoiling it for you, but that really does not help inspire anyone to read the books. What I can say is the first book makes a pretty good case for the series. If you liked the first book, keep on going! If you did not like it, or found the action was not to your liking, tread carefully. If you are really into Corran Horn - keep reading. I also liked reading about Bigg's cousin Gavin in particular. You get to see Gavin take on some interesting topics, and I like seeing how his character grows over the first four books.

There is another reason I like this series - I like lower tier characters. It comes from reading comic books, mostly. I love Batman, Spiderman and Daredevil. I also like the little guys - Antman, Blue Beetle, and Green Arrow. For some reason characters living in the shadows of others have an appeal. I could never get into the god-like powers of Superman. Wedge may just be the guy that had to ditch the trench run, Porkins may have come off like a confused pilot who made a mistake, but learning more about them and their struggles is a lot of fun. I am not going to be a hero, I am not going to change the world - I am just another guy getting by. I have always loved the idea that there are no heroes, that the best thing you can do is prepare yourself and let the moment make you a hero. That idea speaks to me, that idea keeps me going and helps me stay positive, so naturally I identify with these characters.

Some people like the finality of ROTJ. Luke reaches Anakin and redeems him, the Emperor dies, and all is right with the GFFA. However, this series shows the turmoil that takes place following ROTJ, that Luke and Anakin righted the force and opened the door to peace for the galaxy. This situation is more real to me, the idea that individuals can bring about change but only with the strength of others behind the individual will the future become a better place.

Son Of Skywalker15
Son Of Skywalker's Datapad Of Thoughts and Opinions
date Posted: Feb 07, 2008 2:40 PM
I actually throughly enjoy the X-Wing series, and I highly suggest first-time EU readers to get to them quickly. (Not skipping major books, of course.)

Wonderful review. The depth of the characters in the early EU series is amazing, and X-Wing series certainly shows us it.
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Feb 07, 2008 3:07 PM
Wonderful review. The depth of the characters in the early EU series is amazing, and X-Wing series certainly shows us it.

Thanks!
I agree the character are aweseom. The EU takes some hits from some fans, but its great to see how authors develop the characters.

comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Feb 07, 2008 3:17 PM
I actually throughly enjoy the X-Wing series, and I highly suggest first-time EU readers to get to them quickly. (Not skipping major books, of course.)

I have read the EU completely out of order. I am neither for nor against it. I really like being up on everything going on in Legacy, even if it spoils things in the X-Wing series. I also like picking what people liked best and focusing on those books. It was funny that I read Allegience before Heir to the Empire. The way Mara is presented between those books is so totally different. When I read Heir to the Empire, I was like - Now I see why everyone loves Mara Jade so much!
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Feb 07, 2008 3:17 PM
Thanks for stopping by Son of Skywalker! The interview you guys did with Drew on the EU Cantina was awesome!
Son Of Skywalker15
Son Of Skywalker's Datapad Of Thoughts and Opinions
date Posted: Feb 07, 2008 5:01 PM
I agree the character are aweseom. The EU takes some hits from some fans, but its great to see how authors develop the characters

Lately I've been a little disappointed with the characterization done in LOTF, but it has been, and is being, done very well.

I really like being up on everything going on in Legacy, even if it spoils things in the X-Wing series.

That's the thing: Even though you know the facts, you haven't read them; felt them the way the author intended to. That's the best part of reading, in my opinion.
Son Of Skywalker15
Son Of Skywalker's Datapad Of Thoughts and Opinions
date Posted: Feb 07, 2008 5:02 PM

Thanks for stopping by Son of Skywalker! The interview you guys did with Drew on the EU Cantina was awesome!

Thank YOU, comanderbly for listening and writing such a great blog entry. We enjoyed the interview immensely, and rough cut of it can be found on the site. :D

I look forward to reading more by you.
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Feb 08, 2008 1:01 PM
Lately I've been a little disappointed with the characterization done in LOTF, but it has been, and is being, done very well.

Yeah I think part of that is the series is maybe a little long. It makes Luke seem somewhat indecisive. Other times I think they need to spend more time developing other characters like Ben. I am keeping an open mind though - the series almost done!

Thank YOU, comanderbly for listening and writing such a great blog entry. We enjoyed the interview immensely, and rough cut of it can be found on the site.

I look forward to reading more by you.

THANKS! :)
jujadark
Confessions of an Alchemist
date Posted: Feb 08, 2008 6:46 PM
How many Star Wars books have you read in total? I've only read about five myself and am working my way through the new Death Star book which is sitting next to me right now (shhhhhhh...yes, I bring it work). I haven't read a Stackpole book yet, but maybe I will now :) Great review, and nice way to wrap it up at the end. Keep writing.
  Smuggler Jedi
Hokey Religions and A Good Blaster at My Side
date Posted: Feb 08, 2008 6:48 PM
Sorry for being late getting to this. I'm glad you picked up the series and enjoyed it thus far. I thought Stackpole did an amazing job telling the story of the "common soldier" so to speak, and by that, I mean the non-Force users. Wedge and Corran Horn became two of my favorite Star Wars characters because of this series.
  Smuggler Jedi
Hokey Religions and A Good Blaster at My Side
date Posted: Feb 08, 2008 6:50 PM
I think you'll enjoy the books by Allston. They are a little different in style, but he tells compelling stories of some unique characters as well. He has become one of my favorites, and I've enjoyed his work in LOTF. I actually have to finish the last one or two books in the series. I had bought them before I moved last summer, and then they got packed. I need to find them and finish off the series.
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Feb 09, 2008 4:27 PM
How many Star Wars books have you read in total?

Hmmm, some I have loned out. I have read about 20 books. My favorites are the legacy series, Heir to the Empire, the Darth Bane books, and of course X-wing series 1-4. Some of the stand alone books include Death Star and Rise of the Dark Lord.

I would recomend Heir to the Empire - its a series 3 books, and has a lot of OT nostalgia since Luke is still growing as a Jedi.

Great review, and nice way to wrap it up at the end. Keep writing.

Thanks!
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Feb 09, 2008 4:33 PM
Wedge and Corran Horn became two of my favorite Star Wars characters because of this series.

Funny you mention that, my first exposure to Horn was in Legacy and I thought he was not all the interesting until I read X-Wing. I am a big fan of him now!

I love how Wedge is developing - resisting promotions and making it his duty to pursue the Empire and see their threat extinguished.

I think you'll enjoy the books by Allston.

I am really enjoying Wraith Squadron and like his Legacy books a lot. I like the tension he creates between the members of the Squad.
  • Please log in to post comments