Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date posted: Mar 03, 2008 10:47 AM
Review of Revelation
Warning: Minor SPOILERS from Revelation. I will be discussing topics that are big spoilers from the previous novels.



Revelation is my favorite of Karen Traviss's contributions to the series. I feel this could also be my favorite book of the entire series, but I will hold off on that decision until I read Invincible. Ms. Traviss's previous books followed separate plot lines that involved Boba Fett and his granddaughter Mirta Gev and the rise of Darth Caedus. In Revelation the plot lines finally converge and both become central to the story. As I read the book I felt everything flow together very nicely, unlike in her previous books where I was reading a little Fett, a little GA, some more Fett, some more GA, and so on. I am not complaining about the previous books Traviss wrote, but it was a nice change to have the pieces all fit together.

Traviss is pretty well known for drawing strong comparisons between the Jedi and the Mandalorians. Her ability use a warrior culture to explore an order devoted to peace and justice makes for very compelling and thought provoking discussions. In Revelation Ms Traviss went a step further - she explored the Jedi Order and the Mandalorians as powerful forces with very different views of what is best for the GFFA but still showed both groups to be composed of sympathetic individuals with a desire to help those in need. She took the comparisons I followed with great interest in the Republic Commando series to a whole new level in Revelation.

The story itself is magnificent, in my opinion she does a fantastic job of making the biggest battle very suspenseful and exciting. The action is easily on the level of excitement that took place in Fury. I will also give her credit for presenting Darth Caedus as an interesting Sith Lord. Caedus is finally taking on an identity that sets him apart from his whiny tree hugging roots. When I thought about it some of Caedus's characteristics were introduced earlier books. I think these characteristics, like his stance on droids, got lost in the details. For whatever reason these characteristics finally stick. Believe or not I am starting to like Darth Caedus as more and more of Jacen Solo gets stripped away, despite the character's fascist stance on government. I would love to get into more of the details that make me love this book, but its next to impossible without taking a trip into spoiler country, so I will have to save it for another day.

While I have given the book a strong positive review some fans are not going to share my opinions. I know there are some people who feel that Traviss casts a negative view on the Jedi. I know there are some people who feel her development of Boba Fett is not true to the character's roots. Personally I think Traviss loves the Jedi and the Mandalorians, but what she truly loves is the motivations of the individuals and how the smallest things can put people on totally opposite sides. Sometimes you have to break down big philosophies and look at the pieces to understand where you fit in the bigger picture. For example, most of us probably love democracy, we can all recognize where there are weaknesses, and where the idea of democracy is used to justify things that just do not fit. You cannot blindly follow an idea without scrutiny.

As many bloggers have written, Karen Traviss is very underrated, this is her best Star Wars book (that I have read). When I compare it to her Republic Commando novels its more sophisticated and more balanced, a nice blend of action and character development. Revelation is very well balanced - great story telling, things that make you think, things that make you laugh, and a lot of action.

Granny-Wan
I Am NOT an Old Fossil!
date Posted: Mar 03, 2008 12:06 PM
I know there are some people who feel that Traviss casts a negative view on the Jedi.

That would be me. She hates the Jedi, IMO.

Revelation is very well balanced - great story telling, things that make you think, things that make you laugh, and a lot of action.

You make it sound more interesting that other reviewers have... I might have to think about reading it! Thanks for your outlook.... B-)
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Mar 03, 2008 12:19 PM
That would be me. She hates the Jedi, IMO.

Yeah your feelings are no secret! ;) It's all good! :D

I think one of the reasons I like Karen Traviss's books so much is that her views are so different from that of the other EU authors. I am pretty sure she likes the Jedi though (99.9% sure)! I think she really likes looking at the details of the jedi from a different perspective.

You make it sound more interesting that other reviewers have... I might have to think about reading it! Thanks for your outlook...

Yeah I seem to be in the minority based on reviews I read. But no one has said they hated it.
Granny-Wan
I Am NOT an Old Fossil!
date Posted: Mar 03, 2008 1:12 PM
Yeah your feelings are no secret!

My Force powers are weak when it comes to hiding my feelings... and also, I say, "what the hell!" LOL

But no one has said they hated it.

That's a good point... I've read varying opinions but no outright knock on it... interesting!
  Smuggler Jedi
Hokey Religions and A Good Blaster at My Side
date Posted: Mar 03, 2008 1:42 PM
Great review. I finished Revelation last night. I'm working on my review and hope to have it posted tonight.

I agree with just about everything you've written here. I thought this was Traviss's best work, and it finally made all the Mandalorian stories from Sacrifice pay off.

I'm getting into my review now, so I'll save it for later. Again, nice review. I share your enthusiasm.
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Mar 03, 2008 2:03 PM
I'm getting into my review now, so I'll save it for later. Again, nice review. I share your enthusiasm.

Thanks! Glad I was not the only one! :)

I am hoping to do a review with spoilers at some point - there were some things that took place that I wanted to point out, but I figured it was better to wait until more people read it.
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Mar 03, 2008 2:05 PM
My Force powers are weak when it comes to hiding my feelings... and also, I say, "what the hell!" LOL

I know and that's awesome!!! Lately your comments on the blogs have been awesome!

Honestly its nice to know that any Clone / Mando blog I write I can count on you to comment. :D
  Smuggler Jedi
Hokey Religions and A Good Blaster at My Side
date Posted: Mar 03, 2008 2:09 PM
I am hoping to do a review with spoilers at some point - there were some things that took place that I wanted to point out, but I figured it was better to wait until more people read it.

I hear you. This is a hard novel to review without getting into spoiler territory. My review may contain more spoilers than usual.
  DarthBroccoli
Search your feelings, you know it to be true.
date Posted: Mar 03, 2008 3:23 PM
I loved the book also. I'm ready for the series to be over though, cause I'm getting a bit sick of people kicking Jacen's (sorry, Caedus's) butt, and then he gets away. Suspense can only go so far.
Irwin03
CDS: The Art Side of the Force
date Posted: Mar 03, 2008 5:52 PM
We are in 100% agreement, my friend! Possibly my favorite book in the series. I especially loved the dialogue at the end between Jaina and Gotab. It just seemed to tie everything that had happened in the book together. Great review!
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Mar 03, 2008 7:05 PM
I'm ready for the series to be over though, cause I'm getting a bit sick of people kicking Jacen's (sorry, Caedus's) butt, and then he gets away.

Yeah! It's been a long series, and I am ready to see how its going to play out.

We are in 100% agreement, my friend! Possibly my favorite book in the series. I especially loved the dialogue at the end between Jaina and Gotab. It just seemed to tie everything that had happened in the book together. Great review!

Yeah I also really enjoyed that part of the novel. There was also some great dialogue with Boba Fett.

Thanks!
Granny-Wan
I Am NOT an Old Fossil!
date Posted: Mar 03, 2008 7:34 PM
Lately your comments on the blogs have been awesome!

You have to catch me in the right frame of mind... or I should say, the "correct" frame of mind... most here would say I'm never in my right mind.... LOL

As much as I wanted to smack Anakin upside the head, I'd really love even more to take a lightsaber to Jacen.... B-)
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Mar 04, 2008 7:26 AM
As much as I wanted to smack Anakin upside the head, I'd really love even more to take a lightsaber to Jacen....

I second that! I am definitely eager for Invincible!!! B-)
YainiFett
Kyrimout Mountains: Contest time people!
date Posted: Mar 26, 2008 6:31 AM
Cant wait for Invincible either. Revalation was so good because you found out about Venku and other characters from RC series. I'm a bit obssessed with Traviss and mandos and am going so far as to learn the language.Oh good blog ner vod !
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Mar 26, 2008 10:29 AM
Revalation was so good because you found out about Venku and other characters from RC series.

Yeah that was definitely a big plus for me reading the LOTF series. I am also very excited about the next RC novel, Order 66. ;)

I'm a bit obssessed with Traviss and mandos and am going so far as to learn the language

Yeah I messed around with it a few months back but thats about it. :) I really like Mandos a lot and really like where Traviss is taking them.

Oh good blog ner vod !

Thanks!
  • Please log in to post comments