Hello, you are not signed on.
[ Blogs.starwars.com ]

You Must Unlearn What You Have Learned
date posted: Mar 25, 2008 1:30 PM
The Inner Voice
Although I may have touched on this idea in past entries, I don't think I've ever developed it in this light. As the prequel trilogy events unfold, I'm struck by how many different voices Anakin is listening to, which seem to tug him in different directions. The Jedi Order preaches discipline and restraint, Palpatine preaches letting your emotions run wild and giving into them at every opportunity, and Anakin's feelings for Padme inject love into the whole equation, thus really conflicting the poor kid. :p

Ultimately, in life we also hear different voices telling us what to do and which path to take. The great key for us is to focus on the voice that is truly acting in our best interests in telling us what to do. In Anakin's case, he continued to listen to the dark voices, thus leading him to make decisions he would come to regret. Ultimately, he failed to learn from those decisions thus coming to have the voice he listened to haunt him for the rest of his life. The sad part is how he failed to learn from the decisions he made. Slaughtering the Tuskens didn't give him the power to raise the dead, but he failed to recognize that giving into darkness does not grant one greater power when seeking to save the life of your wife.

The tragedy here is that Padme's voice was one of compassion. Despite her choice to either ignore, overlook, or believe that she could save Anakin, Padme still wanted what was best for him. She truly loved him, and even as she felt powerless to stop him from running full speed with no thought whatsoever about what he was doing into the lava shores of Mustafar, that didn't stop her from pleading with him to make the right decision.

As often happens, especially in Star Wars, history repeats itself. When we finally see Luke again, he is much like his father, right down to the conflicting voices competing for his attention. And like Anakin, Luke makes some questionable decisions. Despite warnings from Yoda, he takes his lightsaber into the cave. He runs off to help his friends, headfirst into the trap Vader has set for him. Ill prepared to face a Dark Lord of the Sith, Luke gets his clock cleaned and learns a horrifying truth. His worldview shaken however, Luke listens to the voice of his trusted friends. He may have made a mistake in rushing off to face Vader, but he's not going to compound it.

And from this experience, a new voice emerges, one that tells Luke there is still good in his father. One that helps Luke to believe in the good man that his father once was. And the second time Luke faces Vader, he is better prepared. He still makes mistakes as he gives in to Palpatine's goading, but with wisdom born of experience, Luke chooses not to listen to Palpatine when the final decision presents itself. Learning from his mistakes, passing through the trials and tribulations have taught Luke to trust the one voice that truly wants what is best for him. So he throws aside his lightsaber and shows compassion to his father. In so doing, Luke offers Vader one last chance to listen to the voice that truly loves him and wants what is best for him. And so Vader at long last, listens to the voice of love and compassion, rises up and throws off the dark chains that have bound him all these long years and again feels the Light of the Force in his life.

DJ Maul: Got Feet?
DJ Maul's Dancin' Cantina Party
date Posted: Mar 25, 2008 8:24 PM
bravo! well done! dwell on this I will, perhaps after some time I will pontificate further upon it...


Qui-Tom Servo loves Padme
You Must Unlearn What You Have Learned
date Posted: Mar 25, 2008 9:21 PM
Thanks. I'm currently formulating a follow up entry that ties into this one. This entry actually began life as the follow up, but soon enough the two concepts had grown big enough that they each merited their own entry.
  shoppingMaul61
date Posted: Mar 25, 2008 10:13 PM
A lot of the Skywalkers' reliance on 'other voices' was a direct result of the Jedi being less than forthcoming with facts. In the PT the Jedi constantly talk around Anakin, as if he's not in the room! Later poor Luke isn't even given the benefit of explanation. Instead he gets 'points of view' and truths that emerge only when it suits the Jedi. No wonder these dudes were conflicted!
  shoppingMaul61
date Posted: Mar 25, 2008 10:19 PM
PS Palpatine makes one of the most telling and fascinating observations in the whole saga. He points out that 'good is a point of view', and goes on to elaborate on the Jedi's adherence to it's own dogma as similar to that of the Sith. Obviously he was in the midst of seducing Anakin, but he also exposed one of the most interesting aspects of the series (for me anyway!) when he made these points. How much of Anakin's downfall was the result of Jedi dogma overshadowing the subtleties of human complexity and need? Things to ponder...
Qui-Tom Servo loves Padme
You Must Unlearn What You Have Learned
date Posted: Mar 25, 2008 10:36 PM
Very interesting points. As much as I like the Jedi, I think they made a series of bad decisions not just pertaining to Anakin that set the stage for the fall of the order. I've even developed a theory that Anakin's destiny was to balance the Jedi Order by reshaping it in such a way as to allow families. When he fell to the dark side, he lost that "birthright." I think the Jedi, while still generally "good" had become too entrenched in their ways, thus giving Palpatine an opening.
  shoppingMaul61
date Posted: Mar 25, 2008 11:11 PM
Well said. Great blog too by the way!
I remember when I first saw TPM (and loved it!) I felt that the Jedi may well have misread their own prophecy, and that the required 'balance' was in fact the return of the Sith. Light cannot exist without darkness, yin/yang and soforth! The Jedi were obviously entrenched in dogma and, to an extent, blinded by it. George dismissed that thought, but it's an interesting idea. In that respect perhaps Anakin did fulfil the prophecy by taking a fall - and Luke cleaned up the mess! Luke could then restore the Order without the baggage of old dogma.
What fun SW is!
comanderbly
That's Impossible. Even for a Computer.
date Posted: Mar 26, 2008 10:43 AM
Great blog!

I agree, Anakin was not able to listen to the voices of those around him. I think Anakin never accepted that there are things in life that cannot controlled by power - such as his dreams of Padme dying in child birth. Many of the voices he was hearing were from people that did accept that not everything can be controlled.
ewanandhaydenfan5
I Have You Now!
date Posted: Mar 26, 2008 11:12 AM
He may have made a mistake in rushing off to face Vader, but he's not going to compound it.
Right. Luke may have inherited Ani's flaw of being impetuous, but unlike his father, Luke wasn't arrogant and didn't crave all-encompassing power. His intentions were noble and compassionate. And he learned from his mistakes.

Luke offers Vader one last chance to listen to the voice that truly loves him and wants what is best for him.
Beautiful! I think by then Vader was ready to listen, even if he didn't consciously realize it.

Qui-Tom Servo loves Padme
You Must Unlearn What You Have Learned
date Posted: Mar 26, 2008 11:45 AM
comanderbly, I love your points about those who had accepted that you can't control everything. So much of Anakin's problems stemmed from Palpatine. He told him exactly what he wanted to hear, to the point of convincing the boy that he could be a god as it was. Lucas even noted this in talking about how Anakin became Vader when he asked for and was denied the power of a god.

ehfan5, your thoughts remind me of what old Anakin said to Luke in something(maybe the radio drama) that he was proud Luke had become the man that he (Anakin) wanted to be. While Anakin still bears responsibility for his decisions, it's worth remembering that Palpatine did a brilliant job twisting and molding Anakin from an impressionable age.
Granny-Wan
I Am NOT an Old Fossil!
date Posted: Mar 27, 2008 12:14 PM
It's all about trusting in the Force.... search your feelings

it's worth remembering that Palpatine did a brilliant job twisting and molding Anakin from an impressionable age.

Palpatine was truly the master of evil... wherever there was a weakness, he exploited it... his inner voice must have been strong, although evil... he even manipulated the Jedi Council...

In telling Anakin everything he wanted to hear, he twisted Anakin's inner voice to suit his own purposes...
Qui-Tom Servo loves Padme
You Must Unlearn What You Have Learned
date Posted: Mar 27, 2008 12:28 PM
Agreed. The tragedy of Anakin is that he left slavery only to become Palpatine's slave. And it certainly didn't help matters that the Council deferred to his title a little bit too much. While a coup may not have been the best idea, they didn't have to follow along with most of what he wanted.
Darth_Hiram
A Journey into The Force
date Posted: Mar 27, 2008 9:22 PM
Good blog. Anakin was sure led along by several voices ... that of Padme, that of the Jedi, that of Palpatine, and that of his own. He ultimately made the decision to sever Mace's hand and fulfill his destiny as Sidious's right hand man (pardon the pun!). But he indeed was goaded into his role by Sidious himself, and didn't have the experience or know-how to stand up to him. He allowed Sidious's voice to penetrate his very soul and it made him think exactly what it wanted him to think.

Again, great blog!
  • Please log in to post comments